Judge feedback

Judge feedback is anonymous and shown in a random order.

• Quest Rating: 4.5/5 Stars 1. Fun Factor (5/5) Engagement: The quest is highly engaging, filled with humorous elements like the goblin poo trap and the antics of the goblin queen. The unpredictable outcomes keep players entertained. Pacing & Challenge: The quest maintains a good pace, balancing light-hearted fun with moderate challenges suitable for beginner to intermediate players. 2. Design (4/5) Polish: The quest is well-crafted with attention to detail, particularly in the creative mechanics and varied monster encounters. Logic & Flow: The storyline follows a logical progression, although the linearity limits exploration. Some mechanics could be clarified for smoother gameplay. 3. Narrative (4/5) Immersion: The comedic tone immerses players in a whimsical adventure, complemented by consistent goblin lore. Consistency: Despite the humor, the quest maintains thematic coherence within the HeroQuest universe. 4. Staying Power (4/5) Replayability: While the quest’s linear nature limits replayability, the humor, variable trap outcomes, and goblin behavior add some replay value. Accessibility: The quest is approachable for new players, with clear mechanics and a forgiving difficulty curve. Feedback: 'Goblin Based Nonsense' is a refreshingly fun and creative quest. The goblin poo mechanic and quirky storyline are standout features. To improve replayability, consider adding branching paths or alternate objectives. Enhancing clarity around certain mechanics, like search rules, would also benefit gameplay. Overall, this quest is a delightful addition to any HeroQuest session, offering both laughs and adventure. Final Verdict: A highly entertaining quest that excels in humor and creativity, making it a memorable experience for players.
• Smelly goblins play a key part in this quest - a really fun twist on some of the core game mechanics on show here too (if a little smelly!) - well done.