Judge feedback

Judge feedback is anonymous and shown in a random order.

• Submission Tier:                                   Search for a Star               

  Assessor: Anthony O’Donnell          Lead Artist           Firesprite

  As this is a WIP piece with no final game assets I'll review it as such. Given the limited assets to review it'll be brief.

  The production diary is presented well but does not go into much detail regarding the workflow.

  The sculpt is really good and the likeness of the subject is captured well and noticeably like the reference. The boots are nicely designed and detailed. The use of Marvelous Designer benefited the clothing as it looks great but seems to have been a challenge. 

  The "final" presentation images are posed well and look decent. It's unfortunate this piece wasn't completed. Can't wait to see the final result.

• Nice dynamic pose, and the beginnings of some good cloth work, but overall feels a bit half finished

• Overall the character sculpt is quite impressive, However the goal of the competition was to create a game ready asset. 

  Proportions are looking pretty good and the clothing + marvellous work is very high standard - id say the next thing to focus on would be face anatomy. 

• keep on practising the sculpting skill level is good, but dont forget about all other parts of the process