In game development, every pixel on screen contributes to a player's experience. And while stunning graphics, engaging storylines, and smooth mechanics often get the spotlight, UI (User Interface) design is just as critical — if not more so. A poorly designed UI can confuse, frustrate, and ultimately drive players away, regardless of how good the rest of your game might be.
Let’s break down the most common UI design mistakes that push players away and how to fix them.
The problem:
First impressions matter. When players boot up your game for the first time and are hit with a cluttered HUD, an overcomplicated menu, or no clear sense of where to go next, many won’t stick around to figure it out.
The fix:
Keep the onboarding experience simple. Use progressive disclosure — show players only the information they need when they need it. Don’t throw the entire UI at them in the first 10 minutes.
The problem:
A bloated UI filled with meters, icons, tooltips, and flashing buttons can be just as bad as one that offers no useful information. Either extreme frustrates players.
The fix:
Design your UI to support decision-making. Prioritize what’s essential in any given moment — health, objectives, abilities — and make secondary information accessible but unobtrusive. Give players control over what they see (customizable HUDs go a long way).
The problem:
If your game’s buttons, fonts, icons, and interaction patterns keep changing, players lose trust in the UI. They start second-guessing every click and button press.
The fix:
Maintain visual and functional consistency. Follow a clear style guide for typography, spacing, and interactions. If the "back" button is in the top left in one menu, don’t move it elsewhere in the next.
The problem:
Menus buried inside menus. Crafting screens with vague labels. Unclear key bindings. These all result in wasted time and player frustration — especially in fast-paced or competitive games.
The fix:
Design with predictability in mind. If a player has to stop and think, “Where do I go to equip my weapon?” your UI has failed. User flow testing with real players is key here. Watch where they get stuck, and simplify.
The problem:
Tiny fonts. Poor contrast. No support for colorblind players. These oversights don’t just inconvenience players — they exclude them.
The fix:
Build your UI with accessibility in mind from the start. Offer scalable text, colorblind modes, high-contrast themes, and remappable controls. The wider your audience can interact with your UI, the better your retention.
The problem:
Players want to play your game, not fight with your UI. A cluttered HUD that takes up half the screen can kill immersion. Similarly, frequent interruptions (pop-ups, tutorials, UI alerts) can break the game flow.
The fix:
Prioritize a minimalist approach. Let the gameplay shine and only surface UI elements when they're truly needed. When possible, integrate UI elements diegetically think of how games like Dead Space use the character’s suit to show health and ammo.
The problem:
Your team might love your UI, but that doesn’t mean your players do. Ignoring feedback is a fast track to negative reviews and poor retention.
The fix:
Watch how real players use your interface. Set up playtests and usability studies. Pay attention to what frustrates them, what confuses them, and what they avoid. Then iterate, iterate, iterate.
The best UI is the one players don’t notice — because it’s intuitive, responsive, and frictionless. When UI becomes a barrier, it breaks immersion and pushes players out of the experience. But when done right, UI becomes a powerful tool that enhances gameplay, keeps players engaged, and encourages them to return.
So, next time you’re polishing your combat system or tweaking your level design, take a moment to check your UI. Because no matter how great your game is, a bad interface might be the reason your players never stick around long enough to find out.
Did you like this post? Tell us
Leave a comment
Log in with your itch.io account to leave a comment.