Comments

Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.

Viewing most recent comments 697 to 736 of 876 · Next page · Previous page · First page · Last page

Ok so I just wanna say that I made a horrible decision playing this game at night during a stormy weather which means that as I played this, the lights would occasionally flicker, I'd sometimes hear something crashing outside, and the wind was so fucking strong it felt like the windows were about to blown off. Overall, it just added a much more scary atmosphere as I got further into the game and I genuinely got goosebumps during certain parts. This is such a great game and this is the first time I got scared of a visual novel.

SPOILER:





One thing I still can't completely comprehend though is what the fuck happened during Flynn's route? I just finished it and was so confused. I mean, I got the gist of it that he turned into THE monster but everything seemed so vague to me or maybe I just haven't connected the pieces. Can someone help?

I wish there was some sort of alternate ending to Flynn route. The current one is hella sad and scary.

(+1)

SPOILER for Flynn's route

--------







So long story short: Flynn  was sent through time loops thanks to The Embrace. All endings are canon and all happen at the same time. I'd recommend hopping in the game's discord for quicker answers

OMG you're right! I just now noticed that!

hi hi, i wanted to ask for help for something i just discovered. There's a picture you find in Chase's old house, right? I wanted to find the second of three, but I don't know how, can someone help me? if I'm not mistaken, it's on the Flynn route.







God, this game is very good, I get chills every time that demon (hahah) appears and every time something becomes serious or something appears (like the fake Chase) I start to water with fear and this is very good, THIS GAME IS SIMPLY PERFECT.

Thank you very very very much for making this game!!!

(2 edits)

So I have a question regarding the end of Flynn's route. It seems a bit confusing but...














Does Flynn become the monster and go back in time? Because I'm pretty sure that small fox he was interacting with is a young Jenna

Flynn route ending is tough to explain. I think Flynn got possessed by the spirit and stuck in a loop that always ends up in the past when jenna was kid. IDK man

(+1)

OMG 

I just realise  

(BIG SPOILERS ALERT)










It's like a circle

Sam (kill) his buddy in the mines

Sydney father(kill) Sam

Sydney (kill) his father

Chase (kill) Sydney 

but any of them have kill on purpose, it's like they story have been already writte.

i don't know why but i got a feeling than Chase will be (kill) by Janice's nephew in Archer cause Janice was there when Sam was killed and Janice's ancestor was William.

this will make a true circle...

but i only suppose 😅

You mean Jack (TSR)? 

If he is... True, Sam killed Jack on the mines but he only did that... because of what Jack done... You know!... Sam only defend himself..

(But, we will find out, about that...)

(-2)

Yesterday i write theory about Echo and about Chase n the gang but my post was deleted. Did i was right on some part ?? 😅

(+2)

If you're the person who wrote the comment directly below, your post was probably deleted because you started with a major spoiler for the end section of Flynn's route on the main page's comments without giving any spoiler warnings. Whether you were right or not is irrelevant, it's more for protecting people who haven't completed the routes.

You have to remember that just because you and a lot of others are up to date, not everyone is.

it doesn't mean your right, you just didn't put a warning for spoilers lol.

Deleted 3 years ago
(+1)

Maybe put a warning before massive spoilers, thanks.

(-2)

did you not finish the others route ???

How can you ?? 😂

 sorry for the spoilers, but I'm kinda confused....could anyone probably give me a hand? 






for Leo, he refused to move leave  Echo to take care of his family, which is why Chase broke up with him, because the wolf thing to take care of the pack,  according to the beginning of stories, right?

but in the meantime he said all his siblings already moved out, even his parents moved to Payton,  and they already tried to sell the house.  so why was him stuck in there , even at the cost of breaking  up?  especially when the economic in Echo was at bay for like an century already?  he could have just moved and open the family shop some elsewhere,just like his parents already did.

(+1)

Spoilers mainly for Leo's Route









Leo wanted to stay in Echo for a number of reasons. He refused because he's stubborn, which is why the best ending means you HAVE to break up with him. Chase HAS to move on to get out. Part of Echo's supernatural effects is a burden. A burden of guilt, of trauma, weighing you down and keeping you still. Leo was ironically one of the more affected ones by Sydney's death, not that anyone got off scott free. More to say that it seems Leo's trauma response was to tighten up the group, and refuse to let them go, to let it go, out of fear. Moving out of Echo is a change, a big one. Leo cant do change. Even after what happened, in basically every route he STILL doesn't move. His trauma response was perfect for the curse of Echo to feed off of, keeping him there. His only reason for staying wasn't just his family, that was more so an excuse.

thanks a branch. I fully understand that chase HAS to leave Echo, to survive, to the least.
but for Leo, do you mean he used family as a excuse,  to cover his fear?  after rechecked the leo line, I figured that it's a logical theory.  just want to make sure if I get you right.

Yeah. His family is an excuse to justify it to himself and to others.

(1 edit) (+1)

There is/might be spoilers, I'm sorry.


This story has never emotionally fucked with me in a way I've never seen before, I played a long time ago, and every time I think about it, that twisting feeling in my gut, the increase in heart and breathing rate. Breaths and chest feel heavy, just thinking about the word Chula. Yesterday I decided to play again, in thought I could muster the strength to play again, I was deeply wrong, my heart rate almost constantly stayed up and I started to shake and fidget, when someone happened that was just too much all I could think was "fuck x24" I did Leo's route first and it hurts my heart knowing you can never truly have him, through his obsession that he could be yours forever, he is a poor baby and needs hugs and cuddles. Then I played Flynn, and at one point I didn't wish to continue. it hurt so much to watch Leo go, to act like your not interested, I don't care what he did. Leo was amazing, he is so kissable and huggable. 

It's the next day since I played it, and I'm hungry but if feel like if I ate I would throw it up, no distraction in my life can distract me from remembering Leo and him calling Chula. I will be wired for a couple of days. So this is my warning. The warning atop should seriously be taken into account because I've never felt worse. Getting close and attached to the characters will only hurt you. It's a great game that can conjure these feelings but awful because it does the opposite of Adastra.

Thank you for anyone who is reading, I wanna know how you felt when you played if its an overwhelming game.

(+1)

very much alike feelings shared. 

though I still got a dump dreaming for an ending  where Leo got not SO heartbroken  in the Jenna's route. 



/////////////////////spoilers apologies & warning///////////////



At the very beginning there's a  choice telling her that you were gay, remember? sounds to me like a chance. 
especially when  in this route, even the possessing ghost itself was kinda took enough of it, so he showed up and told Chase IN THE FACE that  who is actually hurting Leo. so at least Chase knew that Leo is possessed. yet the madness isn't really started, lol.


by the way, I tried to convince myself that Leo isn't so loving as it seems, by some details found in Echo Route 65

if you remember there was a website where Leo looked for lawnmower.  look again at WHEN. and see  for how long he did NOTHING with what he found in there.  not even a short message.

didn't very much working on me, still trying though. 

P.S., it is VERY NOT RECOMMENDED for you to play route 65 , if you haven't yet. because knowing what will happen in Echo main story,  Route 65 will be unbearably sad and bitter  to you.  it is about how the couple got together in the first place at their high school.  

I feel exactly the same! I have anxiety and depression and omg, I've never been this worse, and I love it! How could such a great writing makes this with me. Leo's my favorite, and it hurts me so much that him couldn't be "happy" with Chase. It's been more than a week and I still feel bad, and anxious, and, like, don't wanna eat anything.

Though, I like to think that I, myself kinda take care of him in the end, idk I like to think that way. Put youself together dude! It's just a VN, Leo's fiiiiine! He's gonna find someone who loves him for real.

Chase is so terrible omg lmao. Sorry my bad english anyway, I'm from brazil, probably my english sucks but idc.

Also, I never want to play this game again, at least not now. I want to take MONTHS away from this VN actually. I love it of course but it hurts too much.  Sorry for being cringe

I LOVE this game, it’s my second furry novel after adastra, however I needed help with something, I’ve been playing Jennas route and I got to a “to be continued” part, that led me to discover that this game is still in development. Which is awesome! But then I noticed there was an update 4 days ago, I downloaded Echo about 2 weeks ago and I was wondering how I update it? Do I just reinstall to the new version? And will it save all my save files and choices I’ve made so far? Any help would be greatly appreciated!

yet the Jas route isn't finished in the 0.50 version. have to wait a little more.

haven't played this in so long, but why is the audio so loud? 
there is no option to turn it down in the settings.

Omg if the spirit that talks with Chase is who I think it is then The Smoke Room won't have a good ending as well :P

Massive, Major Spoilers for other routes and later into the game...














The thing possessing Chase isn't actually Samuel, it's more of a twisted facsimile of him. An Echo (!), if you will. It's strongly implied in Jenna's route that the real Samuel survived the events of The Smoke Room in 1915, and returned to Echo only to be run over by Sidney's father and Janice, the coyote that works in the diner when they were much younger. From there I theorise the spirit that poses as Samuel latches onto Sidney's father, then onto Sidney, and finally onto Chase.

Or maybe I'm thinking too much about it and want Samuel to have a happy ending because I like him so much more than Chase.

(1 edit)

Omg I finished TJ route and I can't believe what Chase and TJ had done with Sydney, from what I get it there is like two spirits? I liked your theory but it seems like there is two entities, one is supposed to be Samuel and other the curse that there is in Echo, because if you think carefully and see some details in TJ's rote like the format of the words, it seems there is a evil thing "helping" Chase solve his problems telling him to kill Flynn and everything end right and while that happens there is a conversation with other word style saying things like this is a cycle, we're puppets trying to make him notices that he's being manipulated, but at the same time I think Chase is a bad person with this curse messing his mind or not because it never mentioned him regretting what he's done with Sydney he doesn't feel even a bit bad for it and I thought TJ was good at the beginning but he just looked everything happen and pretended again nothing happened. I think the curse of Echo just make their personalities and wishes more intense making they do these things, like Leo's route he clearly was obsessed with Chase and his jealousy just getting worse as time passed, and the bad end of this route just makes everything more clear, in my opinion there isn't happy end but you got it right lol, maybe I change my opinion as I do the other routes but with everything I know until now I have this theory in mind...

Edit: I was remembering what happened and the evil entity could be a twisted version of Sydney as well, they are like a vengeful spirit, his business was with Chase and his friends so he would make them go crazy, and the twisted version of Samuel don't have anything to do with them so he would be more aware of the situation and try to make Chase fix things and break these cicles of tragedy and revenge, there are some points that don't make sense but I guess it's kind of what's happening, and don't worry I want Samuel to have a good ending as much as you do ;)


Theres one separate entity that is a force over the town, manipulating people. These people die and become wraiths, shadows of their former selves and are the more....specific entities. The burned creature for example(that Jenna mentions seeing and is seen when they ride in the van in multiple routes) is a specific character. We know who it is. And their actions line up. There is a "boss" so to speak, tormenting people on a very general level, assumidly to feed on their misery or fear or whatever. We MIGHT have seen said boss in Flynn's route, but thats up to interpretation. Depending on that, we have at least 3 known and named entities in the Burned Man(Flynn's route), Chase's shadow(Possibly? End of Leo's route/the Smoke Room prequel for context), and possibly Sydney(again, Flynn's route).

Ohhh that's some important information, I need to play the other routes to know everything better, I don't know what to think about the Burned Man thought 🤔 it's the thing that crashed the car and made everyone fell into the lake in Leo's route right? In the end of his route I first thought that shadow was Sydney but that wasn't making sense, like he was just watching Chase making bad choices, making Leo go crazy and enjoying this madness but I agree that's probably Chase's shadow there, the way he is afraid of his reflection of his form, he even mentioned seeing a dark form just like him watching right? And until where I know that's the only route this happens soo... No wait the mirror thing happens in TJ's route lol, but he's afraid of something that looks like him this I remember, I wonder if there's a way to beat this boss, a way to set everyone's soul free, maybe breaking the cycle? It would be great to have a Echo 2 with all the answers we are seeking for, but I feel like this isn't what the creators want to do, I guess this story is more interpretation style letting the players have their conclusions of what's happening and discuss like how we are doing now you know lol, and they would have to make an ending canon which it wouldn't be cool right what I think it's cool about this game is how each route is different in some ways from another and each one has a completely different story or ending, even the feelings that they bring with the events you know that's amazing or they could make more routes according to the one we choose in the first one, it is a lot of work to do so I don't think it would be possible maybe?

You also see chase's shadow in Jenna's route, in honest to god one of the scariest fucking things in the entire game.

Man. I felt kind of bitter during TJ's route. Only choices are pretty much near the beginning and don't see them impact the outcome. Not sure if I missed a particular setup but yeah... how conflicting. 

I know you cannot change what happened in the past (or can you... wibbly wobbly spooky Echomagic... would actually be cool if this and The Smoke Room fused to become convoluted in your choices! Muahaha). Granted what you see in little snippits kinda spoils me for what's going to happen to certain individuals in TSR... (in possible routes.. though clearly they aren't canon... unless we're getting into parallel universes... ouch my smol brain.)

Hope to see more options down the track. I love the game but also despise what I'm made to feel. Happy Endings are kinda bleak for the lil musky otter. :'(

I already finished all of the guys' routes then i forgot Jenna had one as well, so then I started playing it. Now, Im easily scared by horror stuff, so I usually avoid them but I read some comments that this game had no jumpscares or straight up horror elements. Then comes the fookin animated shadow doppleganger of Chase. Goddammit almost made me want to throw my phone and cry what the hellll. 

(+1)(-1)

Someone pls make a oneshot with a happy ending for Leo omg I'm so sad man. Chase is such a asshole for everything, and this ending... I'm happy not for Chase but for Leo, he's finally free from this beast! Sorry my bad english I'm brazillian <3 


Anyway, I reaaaally need more content about Leo, he just became my husbando. A fanfic? Anything aahswhdwshauhsaushsu I'm going crazy! Btw Leo and Janna/Jenna are my favorites. I can't remember her name now lmao I'm such a loser, but I can't help it! Leo just leave echo and come live with me MY BABE <<<3 CHASE YOU NEVER DESERVED HIM YOU SON OF A B

I'm so cringe I can't-

(+4)

Won't lie, I feel the same way about Leo. Leo's good end was still a bad end in a eyes and they did him dirty, big time.

(+4)

the point is that you shouldn't be with leo. literally the best thing that happend to leo is that he got over chase and started living again. if you give in, you continue his obsession. 

(+1)

I know :( it's just, I think I just wanna see him happy again. Not with Chase tho I kinda hate him. And when he said that he was crying everyday before sleep, I kinda wish... idk. I feel bad for him, all his obsession with Kudzu and Chase become real, 'cause they end up together. God I hate this feeling, they can't be together. Sorry again for my poor english 

he is happy, its just that his happiness is caused by leaving chase, and his obsession leaving. and its alright with your english, mine is bad too.

(+1)

I played Leo's route first, and was so disappointed that his "good" ending ended the way it did. I was heartbroken. Playing through the rest of the routes though, I still liked Leo just as much, but really started to hate Chase for what he did, to everyone and to Leo. 

I'm glad him and Leo don't end up together, but I really think Leo deserves a guy that'll treat him right. Chase doesn't deserve Kudzu either frankly, but oh well.

(+1)

Ikr??????

Where can I find the echoproject's discord?

https://discord.gg/Q5Xkgkn here

Did one of the TJ routes has the message "The End" at the end of it?

I only got it for Leo's route and Carl's route (I don't have finished the others yet) 

If one of the TJ's routes have it, can someone tell me the choices I have to choose to get it? 

Thank you 

(sorry for my bad English) 

How many routes are there? I went through TJ's And Leo's

I don't know I didn't went through all of them for now

(+1)

5 routes

(1 edit)

Has Flynn's route been completed yet?

Oh okay thanks, And i forgot to mention. I got "the end" at the 2nd route of leo...

TJ's route only has one ending, so you got it!

Leo and Carl are the only two with multiple endings (so far), though Flynn also gets a "The End."

Ahh thanks i have been going crazy over if im done or not

(1 edit)

I feel like it might be a sign that Arches will take place in this timeline. Every other routes have clear end while TJ's is vague and not really a great closure to the events.

(+2)

I'm working through playing all your visual novels. I just finished both endings for Leo's route as my first play through and wow. Each option is incredibly sad, but also unavoidable. I enjoyed them both immensely and after getting the more negative ending for Leo first I was really appreciative of the alternative, even though it still really hurt. Thanks so much for making such great stories and beautiful artwork to go along with them. This story has challenged me more emotionally than I was quite prepared for. I can't wait to dive back in to try a different route, get closer to other friends in the group and hopefully learn more about the mystery of Echo. 

Possible spoiler for Adastra and Khemia: 

I especially appreciate how the concept of the other that we see in Adastra is already present in this earlier work. How it manifests across the universe in small pieces and larger concentrations plays out really directly here. Brian's arc and his experience in the mine was especially chilling. I don't know if I've ever hated a character as much as him and been so satisfied with the conclusion of their story. The ways in which the other gets its tendrils into him and appears to him in different ways is not only disturbing and moving, but probably not too far off from real life.

(+3)

I love all the visual novels you made

Deleted 2 years ago

Murdoch as a character wasn't created until after that chapter of Echo was released. He wasn't mentioned by the spirit because the writers hadn't even come up with the idea for the character yet.

(1 edit)

(Spoilers, kinda)









Why doesn't Flynn have multiple endings like the others? it seems kinda strange, especially with the 5 years later thing wgere it shows chase and them college kids

My best guess is that his ending is necessary for tying together all of the routes. If it ended any differently, people who got a different ending wouldn't have any sort of closure for certain events on Leo or Jenna's routes. That being said, of course I wish there were an alternate ending for him (and TJ for that matter).






As for the five years later thing, those college kids are in every ending so far with the exception of Carl's I believe. They'll be part of a sequel that the team is working on!

(+2)
"CW: Echo can be an emotionally intense experience"

THAT IS QUITE THE UNDERSTATEMENT JESUS HECK.


No spoilers but DAMN, y'all did not hold back and just- the ending of TJ's route... DAMN. Gonna give it a go for other's routes but I need to recover from everything I just- well I just need to recover from everything.


Minor minor spoilers, but I wish towards the end there, on the lake, or honestly any appropriate spot before, I could've had some sort of choice to stop all... THAT... from happening, but that's not on y'all being bad writers or anything that's just me always wanting a perfectly happy ending all tied up with a neat bow. Typically after stories that aren't even half as... Intense... as this I find myself daydreaming about me being in total control and fixing everything and it all being happy and hunky dory.


TL;DR: Great- no ABSOLUTELY FANTASTIC story and characters, but highly stressful and anxiety inducing, especially for a control freak that always wants everything to go perfectly and happily.

(+1)

ikr my anxiety went all over the place when i first played this ;-; but still it was an amazing visual novel 

little spoiler

What  specie is Sydney? I guessing he's an otter too, since in Flynn's route he sees him as one at the bar.

Yes, he is an otter. That is mentioned very early on actually.

Oh, I must have missed it. Thanks!

sorry google translator)
(careful spoiler)
I went the path of Leo (my first path) in the game and I liked the ending, but is there an outcome in which we stay with Leo, but we DO NOT REMOVE LEGS AND WE DIE! and if so, how to get it. Thank you in advance.

Nope. Either you stay and die or you leave and live.

Ohhh...

it's a little sad but I like the ending, it is logical and overwhelming!
I'm glad Chase found his happiness!

(+1)

So uh, I only finished Leo's route so far b/c haha sexy wolf.
And uh, gotta say I'm thrilled, chilled, and down right terrified at points. 
Now I gotta play through the rest!
The writing is so immersive and entertaining that I can't help but get sucked into the world. 
Thank you for the tears and fears!

(+1)

so SPOILERS but












i feel like the killer for Sydney can actually be different in certain routes?? like for TJ it's Heavily implied that it's Chase (and kind of in Leo's route if i remember) but for Flynn, it doesn't specifically say it was Chase. I almost felt like it implied that it was Flynn (or whatever Flynn was at that point) instead. I'm not sure if that was the intention or not, but the concept that the killer changing each time is interesting.

Really? I didn't get that from FFlynn's route though. In what part is that implied?

i probably read it wrong but i thought that flynn's route implied that maybe he caused it instead, or at least contributed to it? but also i could be wrong idk

No not really. Chase killed Sydney.

Deleted 270 days ago

Sydney's killer you mean? That gets pretty clear at the end of TJ's route.

But there're some strange details that lead you to doubt that Chase really killed him, or at least that he wanted to. For example, in Flynn's route, Leo blames Flynn of killing Sidney and Flynn denies it doubtful. Or sometimes he's not sure if Chase did or not, like he doesn't truly believe it. For me, there is something more. 

Um...so I just played for the first time on Flynn's route. Can someone plz elaborate on what happened? I'm a little confused. 

Also what other routes are currently available?

To understand Flynn's ending more, you have to play Jenna route(which is still on going) you can determined Chase and Jenna relationship to be lover or just friend when she asked Chase if he gay in Amusement park.

Right now all routes are finished except Jenna route. 

(+1)

SPOILERS










Man, everyones's talking about wanting a "good ending" with the MC staying with Leo, but I strongly believe that that's a bad ending. Kudzu seemed to be way more better than Leo, even if we don't have much info about  him. He didn't seem possesive or extremly jealous. Letting Leo leave the past and manage to forget Chase is way more beneficial than build on his happiness over a person. Yeah, he spent 5 years crying for him, but at the end, he let it go. Anyway, this is the only route I've finished so far, I'm hyped to try the others <3

Does the game include smut?

It does but it isn't the focal point.

Um, is Jenna route already finished?

(+1)

Still on going!

Spoilers 







I love the new jenna route update. The animation of chase doppelganger walking behind Leo at The hotell. The smoke room reference when janice hit the maincharacter from tsr with their car. All this freaked me out so bad. But in a good way. Its fucking awrsome!!!!! 

For Flynn's route does to be continued mean it's still wip or is it for an erry effect?

Oh, because...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zunRT0f_PLg&feature=emb_title

SPOILERS!!















Is there a better ending to Flynn's route? I got the ending where Flynn was the monster and was in the closet of who i am assuming is Jenna.  I think "Flynn" drowned Sydney. 

That's the only posible end of Flynn route and there only one thing  wich we can influence on, by choising who's story you want to be completed: Flynn's, Leo's or ... Jenna's maybe ? And I dont think fully possesed Flynn was the killer more likely that *That* thing gave him

all the answers by warping him through time, space and even multiverse's of Echo (as we seen before with Chase's car, it's posible)

and mutilated Flynn" just been an observer of events of the past(only proving point that all going in circles).

Thanks, that clears things up

(+1)

does anyone know where the music is from? like is it just royalty free stuff or did someone produce it?


fantastic game btw !!!

(1 edit) (+1)

there is a bug in Jenna route. Android (maybe spoilers). 




after a fight Leo vs Brain. In hotel, when screen became darker in third time and "Leo eyes are still open" (or something like this with the same meaning) , game just crush. I try to make different choices but that do not change anything at all. I use absolutely new saves.

Same happens to me. I'm not sure if it's supposed to do that, or if there's some special animation or something that crashes the Android version of Ren'Py.

I suppose I could try checking on my desktop, but that would require going through the entire Jenna route again...

(+1)

yeah, i already watch a walkthrough and there is some kind of animation that didn't work on android

Use skip feature

(1 edit) (+1)

I just finished Leo's route and I'm really distraught from it. (The rest is spoilers)



















I loved Leo but to me seemed rude to everyone accept Chase once you got further into this emotional rollercoaster. It proves he is a bit rude by going on Flynne's route. He is mean to Flynn because Flynn is curious to what happened to Sydney and does not know how to ask for the truth.


But I also get why Leo's the way he is. He was stuck in wondering if him and Chase were going to get back together. I have been in a place like that. I understand what he is going through and I feel a lot of sympathy for him.

It gets worse. Play Jenna's route, see what he's been put through

(1 edit)

Please make an ending where you and leo live together as a good ending i really love leo's route so much and it would be nice to see them together at the end.

(1 edit) (+4)

Spoilers (kinda...)




Leo's  Bad ending resume in 2 Words:






FEETus Deletus

(+1)

BOI.

(1 edit) (+2)

Ohhhhhhh!!! I got startled so badly.

SPOILERS!

.

.

.

.

.

.

Jenna's route... that animation! I didn't even know animations were possible in Renpy... Everyone else having static sprites, but that THING casually walking in made me do a double take.

So when is the update coming?

Viewing most recent comments 697 to 736 of 876 · Next page · Previous page · First page · Last page