Comments

Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.

Viewing most recent comments 1 to 40 of 324 · Next page · Last page

Is it weird that my favorite part is your really well thought out lesson plan? Thank you for being so conscientious about it, it felt so very reasonable and served as a great intro to the lore as we learn alongside our little protagonist!

 Discord server link!

Just finished reading up to the end of the current demo and overall I really enjoyed it! 😀

To start with, I'll talk about the parts I had some problems with. There were some points during the last two chapters (3 & 4) while Mordred was going about his daily life/lessons when nothing much was happening and it just felt like a bit of an info (lore) dump. I other words, it sort of dragged and I began to lose interest and skimmed. I wanted to be honest about my personal experience here even if it might not be the glowing praise some would give. Skimming is a subconscious reaction for me when my brain stops feeling engaged and searches for the next point of interest in a story. I'm not saying it was that way for other readers, but it was so far me.

I also lost some interest in the dragons, which somehow feel a little too normalised now, even mundane, and my 'fierce' dragon feels quite tame. I feel it's become a bit lax in upholding that sense of wonder that, as bonded as we may be with our dragon, we should still feel from time to time over these powerful creatures. I also feel that, due to being a Pendragon/Dragonblood, our insight and connection with dragons in general, even if we're cautious in not showing it, should still feel more profound then it does. Like we just perceive them on a level that others (besides Arthur) cannot, even if we're not actively engaging them. I still don't really get that vibe from it.

But other than those bits, I found your writing style is very mature and polished. I really love the way you portray Morgana - she genuinely feels as powerful and formidable as she should feel, and I think she is the character you write best. I'm always interested to see what she'll do next and what little (or not-so-little) schemes she's got cooking. Really nice. Our Mordred is also a well written MC - suitably complex. Lastly, I'm enjoying the building yet conflicted relationship between Mordred and Arthur - I'm really intrigued to see the future difficulties the relationship faces as the two grow closer and Arthur becomes even more conflicted between his trust in Merlin's prophecy and his own (potential) desire to recognise Mordred as his successor, and of course the potential public fallout of such a revelation. But I suppose that's all quite far in the future!
Most importantly, I felt disappointed when I reached the end of the demo and there was no more for now, which is always a good sign. 😊

I also hope we see more of Galahad soon - my male Mordred's chosen LI. So far the parts with him have been my favourite parts of this story (what can I say? I'm a sucker for the enemies-to-lovers trope). I enjoyed the nature of Mordred's relationship with him during our first meeting, and how by the end Galahad is potentially torn between the desire to believe and follow his father and the realisation that his father is not as perfect or right as he originally imagined, and Mordred may not be this world-ender that he's made to believe. I also like the antagonism between them too, and am interested to see how they'll interact when they're reunited after 5 years - what's changed, and how the  attraction blossoms (both advertently and inadvertently) out of what starts out as antagonism. The complexity and changing nature of it is always a fun experience, in my opinion! ❤

I'm also wondering - will it be possible to romance Galahad even if our Mordred doesn't exactly try to befriend him? By that I mean, Mordred might still antagonise Galahad as he does him, but Galahad is observant enough to see how Mordred acts toward people he cares about, and that Mordred may not be quite as "horrible" as all that, not to mention Mordred's teasing flirts (potentially) getting him a bit flustered despite himself. Anyway, it would be interesting to know!

(+2)

As a #galahad historian whose stalked his tag on the blog relentlessly, you can romance galahad without befriending him! As long as you show some romantic interest in him (whether oblivious or knowingly) and try to change his mind on you being Evil McEvilsteen from the Land of All Evil, a romance can happen!

Nice, thanks! 

If I understood correctly there will be no poly routes, right?


Unless all character can be romanced at once, and we woukd have to deal with consequences such as they would be.

(+1)

Well, according to (very old, so don't shoot me if I'm wrong) tumblr asks, you can flirt with ro's as long as you don't get locked into a 'route' beforehand- so, let's say I have a childhood crush on Nimue, but then flirt with Galahad, BUT I also sometimes flirt with Nimue as well. In game, it would probably translate to the two characters experiencing confusion regarding who I'm interested in, and potentially start a few arguments. (At least, from what I understood from, I'll say this again, very old tumblr asks.) 

Ah, understandable.

Thank you for the information.

(+2)(-3)

language! >:(

It warns of 'mature language' at the beginning of the story. What are you complaining about?

(-3)

welcome to the concept of "jokes" and "irony"

(+1)

Hilarious!

(+3)

But what's the build up? What's the punchline? Like, it just seems like a random comment scolding the author for using mature language. If you want random people online to know your joking, frame your joke correctly? 

(-2)

i think the angry emoticon shows that it's satire. also not all jokes have to follow the traditional "buildup to punchline" yk,

(+1)

bros. my guys. i saw the word bastard. i am trying to be funny

(3 edits) (+5)(-2)

My Mordred is very, obviously queer (being both nb amab and attracted to males), so in my head there was this conversation with this one bully girl:

Bully: Your gay.

Mordred: *hugs Gawain* Yes, that's my gay. Go find your own. And it's "you're".

Btw, this is great story, I love how the characters are portrayed, how Mordred's gender feels are handled and how immersed I got. 

I hate writing comments, but for such amazing story, I'm willing to go out of my comfort zone <3

(-8)

amazing lol, but pls dont use the q slur <<33

Hi, just fyi, I'm nonbinary, bisexual and english is my second language <3 I was under the impression that this is a reclaimed term and not a slur, sorry :<

(+3)

It;s reclaimed, the person above just has no idea what they're talking about. 

(-4)

some people like to say they've reclaimed it, but the majority of lgb people think its a slur.

(+4)

yeah, its a slur. its a reclaimed slur. you don't have any right to tell people they can't call themselves queer.

gay is used as a slur, queer is, fag is. I will never stop calling myself queer though. it's some faschist message board that convinced young people it's a slur when it was long used perfectly normally as a great umbrella term.

be offended by the persecution, instead. 

(+4)

It's been reclaimed, and is used in a VARIETY of studies surrounding the lgbtq+ community. Also, people call themselves queer all the time- what, if you saw someone who identified as queer irl, would you say that they're using a slur? As long as it's not used as an insult, it is NOT  a slur in that context, and post like this actively serve to destroy and dilute queer history. Does the word 'gay' not also serve the purpose as a slur, in your reasoning? 

(-3)

so gay means happy, while the q slur means weird and unnatural. your reasoning of "if its not used as an insult its fine" does not hold any weight, would you say the same for the nword? black people reclaimed it and call eachother it all the time, and why'd you give my simple "hey pls don't use a slur" comment so much power? Me asking for lgb people not to be called weird and unnatural is erasing lgb history?

(+4)

As a gay person, I, personally am very weird and unnatural.

If you don't like using the word to refer to yourself, that's fine. But you shouldn't ask other people not to use it, especially if they're a random stranger on the internet, because they get to choose what they refer to themself as. Unless it's in person and it makes you uncomfortable, but this is something you don't have to engage in.

(+1)

you don't talk for gay people. only yourself. who is using it as an insult other than you?

(+2)

I hyperfocused on this game so bad that I stayed up until 5am like it’s so INTERESTING and I love how you can shape the story but your own individual choices matter. I saw someone ask if there’s a discord and I would like to be apart of that. 

(+1)

This is one of my favorite games on itch.io, keep up the great work!

(1 edit) (+1)

A minor suggestion: currently you're using black heart icon to mark explicit romance options, while the oblivious romance icon comes red colored. If you wanted to make things look uniform (i.e. all these heart icons being red) you could replace the black heart icon with this one: ❤️ (U+2764 U+FE0F) A simple search&replace would handle it.

(+1)

Me making fate series mordred in this game, best decision ever because it actually goes with the story so well.

(+2)

when I get my bank working istg I'm subbing to the patreon I crave more media of this series!!!!! I Crave ittttttt

(+3)

Man, I hope we get to accomplish our mothers' revenge. I would love a scene where after defeating all her enemies, soaking and covered in their blood, we bow to her with the crown in our outstretched hands and say something along the lines of "What was owed will be repaid, this crown only one of the countless victories I will bring before you, Mother, Queen."

(+2)

I now understand arthur and I feel like a asshole now, I will go cry now.

(+1)(-25)

PLSSSS LET US ROMANCE MORGANA. I CAN FIX HER!!!

Deleted 26 days ago
(+1)(-12)

Look at what she did to our father. Respectfully, this is the only way to redeem her. It has to be done for the greater good.

(+5)(-1)

i cant even list every way in which you are wrong

(+1)(-11)

I can list every way in which I am wrong. Yet, I find that list to be objectively incorrect in every way. The people of Camelot deserve prosperity, and change is required for that. I believe romancing morgana is the perfect catalyst for that change.

If that happens their kid is basically gonna be Daenerys 2.0, and will burn Camelot (and broader Avalon) to the ground atop their dragon.
Thus, Merlin's prophecy would be fulfilled.

Jocasta Syndrome

Morgana is stronger than you. good luck surviving adoptive dad, too. there might be opinions.

xD

(+11)

bro thats our mum wtf

(1 edit) (+9)

When I read this I was like Wtf!? But then I  saw the user name ...now it make more sense

(+2)

HUHHH?????

(+1)

OMG dude……best matches to your name……

(1 edit) (+9)

damn i really am cucking my brother, one of the few people that supported me during my whole life. maybe i am a bastard

(+6)

it's only a problem if he minds...which he very obviously doesn't in game so. take what you will.

(+3)

yeah, i was just at the beginning at the chapter 5 when i commented and thought he would mind since he didn't fight his dad decision

(+1)

Oh lol, I got you. Though if my dad was Lot, I probably wouldn't argue with his decrepit ass. Probably wouldn't have changed anything ngl. 

(2 edits)

Well it depends on the relationship we made the mc to establish with  their brother because if we chose the option that the two siblings were close in the childhood then they are close but what about the other end of the relationship that can become negative, and if we choose our mc hate him then that what happens because as we have seen Gareth is capable of anger both silently and openly when he comes and angryly accuses us for Morgana open affection with Accolon in the tournament(due to the option of choosing to hate him) and also gareth is basically the sibling out of the two that can hide they emotions pretty well and we will never know his thought on the relationship we pursue with his fiance if we are in the hate relaionship with him but if we are close to him, then he reveals he is ok with it, what I am trying to say is that Mc whom hates Gareth should not poke the bear that is pondering wether to devour us the snake in an instant or slowly and painfully 

PH MY GODDDDD

I love it so much!!! It's amazing, can't wait for more!

(1 edit) (+9)

my mc in they childhood: yay when I grow up I wanna be like Accolon

my mc now in they teens: Accolon why are you a simp tell me it not so, I understand she is a thick mommy but why did you have to stoop so low for a baddie like her that is for the street

(+10)

This was actually amazing, ive never been so invested in anything before (please continue this and dont die 😔🙏)

(+6)

😂😂😂  i love your content, please dont die

(+5)

I LOVE THIS GAME SO MUCH, this was such a long demo. It was so entertaining ! 

(+7)(-1)

*Spoilers maybe*







Great story so far! I've only played up until the point were sir Lancelot was minorly poisoned. The part were Morgana says 'Oh tragedy' Reminds me of the whole 'Sorrows. Prayers.' meme

(+1)

“O’sorrow. You see, I have ended, by respecting you, because I am certain you will never leave me”

(+6)

Hello There!

Fantastic Story! It has gotten a grip on my attention that i've found *Very* hard to find release from! I Love how the story seems to balance so well the day-to-day slice of life bits with the more long term happenings. The ROs are all interesting and loveable so far (with perhaps the understandable exception of Nimue, who we only get short interactions with very early on in the story leading to a certain lack of attachment developing towards her)!

The Story itself is incredibly well written and the narrative quite gripping, a very fun and unique take on the Arthurian Mythos. The text feels slightly repetitive in some paragraphs, feeling a tad.... skippable? but that could simply be related to how rapidly and violently i've been ripping through the story.

I also liked the vast amounts of customization you allowed towards the character of Mordred and how progressive you made the setting. Very nice to see  :)

I have encountered a bug near the ending of the current content, when Mordred is confronting their dragon partner about their crush on Elaine's

"Not yet, so shhhhh!" $Dragon_name presses their tail against their snoot, eyes darting in the direction Felix went off. "I just-I'm not sure how to tell them. What if they don't feel the same way? I mean, you've seen them. They're amazing."

All in all i have only praises to sing for this work so far! i'll await further updates eagerly and would most certainly be joining your patreon if i wasn't poor as dirt!

(+4)

Hello! I love your story! Hope this isn't a stupid question, but how do I get access to the full novel instead of demo? I'm new to this website and don't know how to work patreon either. Or is it not complete yet?

(+4)

Hi and thank you! It's still a work in progress. The Patreon version is ahead of the public demo, though currently not by a lot, just the arrival of the wedding guests in chapter 5.

(+4)

Is there a time estimate on the next update?

(+7)

Not yet! What I can tell you is that the next public update will be the second half of chapter 5.

(+2)

hi, dear author! i'm loving the story a lot so far, but there seems to be a bug in the relationship stats – i've just began chapater four,  and the stats are: 

"Gawain:

You don't think much of him.

 Galahad:

It's been five years since you first met, and planted the seed of doubt in his heart."

given that mordred is stated to be 11, and that his first kiss was with gawain in my gameplay, i don't believe those stats are correct, right?

there are also constant strange conjugations regarding my dragon's pronouns, like "they walks" and "they is" – i wasn't given the option to choose my dragon's sex as well, but idk if that's a bug or we just can't decide.

thank you sm for the effort put into this game, i wish it was completely released by now so i could spend my whole damn month on it 💔🫂

(+1)

Hi! Yeah that's def a bug in the relationship stats, will have it fixed! As for the strange conjugations - it's an issue I'm still working on, going everywhere and fixing each typo.

And thank you so much! ❤

(+1)

hi! I am also having this problem. Does this affect the storyline and choices moving forward?

(+1)

Nope, the issue is just with the text in the stat page. Though of course if you notice something strange in the story itself do let me know!

(+2)

What's the word count so far?

(+3)

can't wait for the next chapter!!! I'm excited and curious.

(+3)

A small note: there's a few instances in the game's script where you've used variable named gawain_ro (as opposed to Gawain_ro) This causes some minor bugs, like conditionals which check for Gawain's romance always failing even if he does have feelings for MC, or the romance "score" not getting properly updated. hth.

(+1)

Thank you for catching that! 

(+7)(-1)

This game is definitely shaping up to be one of the best narratives for this genre, and I really appreciate the retelling of the original story in a more open-ended way. It allows us to shape Mordred's personality and opinions, which is great. However, there is one thing that bothered me and kind of disrupted the flow of the story. We're still in the early stages of the overall story, with the author planning to make four books. The first three chapters of book one were fantastic and enjoyable, but chapter four fell apart. I have to say, if the author ever sees this, please tone down the descriptions of pointless places that won't appear again or serve any purpose. Chapter four is filled with an overwhelming amount of text describing things that didn't need that much attention. It's okay to explain places and things to paint a picture for the readers, but when it's done excessively, it slows down the story. Another issue is how slow-paced chapter four is, with all the unnecessary tasks and chores. It feels like filler, as if the author hasn't figured out how to move the story forward yet. I got bored reading it and ended up skimming over the lines of useless descriptions. Thankfully, things pick up near the end, and the ending of chapter four was great. Still, it felt like a missed opportunity. But hey, I'm not the writer of this story, just sharing my thoughts as a fellow game writer. On a positive note, chapter five had a better pace, and the drama and everything were enjoyable to read.

(1 edit) (+4)(-2)

i held that critic to msf until now, since i love the story, its characters and how well-written it is, but i agree with you 🫠 i didn't play chapater 4 yet, but i found myself skimming a third of the paragraphs at chapter 3: there was too much repetion of story beats, like how you'd have to tell other characters again and again the same things – i believe four different characters asked about my relationship with gawain. FOUR. and, since i wanted to be close to all of them, i had to recount things non-stop, even tho my mordred was already certain he liked gawain.

i believe the author doesn't understand yet how telling is equally important to showing, nor when to not include a scene all together. they're totally capable of developing these skills, tho, so i hope they don't read our comments as offensive. i love their attention to details on specific moments – like in the RPG between the little boys scene, my fav part of the book so far, lovely amazing – but there's only so much description of foods and festivities of unimportant npcs you can read until it gets tiresome.

(+4)

so, i'm halfway through chapter 5 now and, yeah... my tip for the author would be to withhold lore until it's necessary. i know we can get excited with world building, but we gotta step back and ask ourselves if we're answering questions the readers, supposedly, must be eager to know by now, or if we're just oversharing at the cost of almost stopping the pace. as for now, different from the first chapters, it's too much information and too little actually happening. chapter 4 was a chore to get through, while chapter 5 literally lectures you on lore. if you're like me and is not that interested on elaine, there's not much to hold your attention, really.

hope the author understands i say those things out of love for the story, aaa 🫠💞 i'm very invested and looking forward to it. i've even been talking about it with my sister! lol. pls, author, don't feel unmotivated by the critics, i'd rather you ignore them all than abandoning this work

(+1)

Unfortunately I agree. I've got ADHD and I absolutely love to read and CYOA games are part of my favourite genres but when it gets to be too much information and world building, my brain loses interest and no matter how hard I try, I can't stay engaged so I just end up skimming until I find something that seems interesting, which is a shame when someone spends so much time writing a full story.

(1 edit) (+3)

This is by far my favorite itch game! I feel really involved in the story by my choices. I love Modred and I want to protect them from the world. There is just one thing that I was really disappointed on. I simply wish that the introductions between the step mom and Modred is not just mentioned, but actually showing me this meeting and providing choices in how this interactions went. Otherwise, the story just feels rushed past the introductions and lacks that emotional tie. At the moment I have little opinion over the step mom because of this skipped scene and little interactions so far.  Despite of this, I'm still a biggest fan and I'm always finding myself replaying this game. You have a great writing talent!

(+3)

Thank you! ❤ I really appreciate the feedback; I wasn't satisfied with Guinevere's lack of content so far, either, so I've decided to make changes to give her an earlier introduction in chapter 3! This way Mordred (and the player) will get to meet her on-screen and interact with her, and we'll also see more of her in Arthur's POVs within that chapter. 

this game is amazing, is there a discord for this?

https://discord.gg/x8NXDhb2qa

thank you so much. Didn’t expect a response to be honest

no problem! its pretty quiet  so feel free to start a conversation...

(+6)

Chapters 1-3 were quite strong but during chapter 4 the story just grinded to a major halt. Lots of time spent detailing locations we'll likely never see again, or random daily tasks that don't actually move the plot forward, yet no time spent detailing our first meeting with our own step mom!? Just a brief line about her having been nice to meet? That's so SAD. I was looking forward to our first meeting :(

Anyway, I can't get past the beginnings of Ch4. I'll wait until the story progresses and then slog my way through when I at least know that there will be lots more content to enjoy afterwards.

Good luck, author. Lots of potential to this story. Please consider making adjustments to Ch4 tho lol. 

(2 edits)

I would like to ask a question ,and if you can't answer that's fine I apologize if it was rude, how may chapters will this story have? NVM I saw someone in the comments answer my question lol but thank you nonetheless for writing this story, so my next question, will we see our character as a young adult or is that for the future novels?

Mordred turns 18 in chapter 6; they'll be 19 for the rest of book one.

how often do updates comme out? when will the next update be??

(+2)

Updates usually come out every time the patreon finishes a chapter, or reaches the midway point. The author broke her wrist a while ago however, so it is probably going to be a while until an update for either the patreon or public demo comes out! 

ok, thank you so much!

Where can I find the portraits of the characters (specifically Gawain, I love him)

as far as i know there is none (dont quote me on that), but if you go onto the authors tumblr theres a pinterest board that shows each of the characters aesthetics and stuff.

(1 edit) (+1)

Galahad got one during a collab with the game dev of infinite stars! She posted the announcement on both tumblr and patreon. 

https://www.tumblr.com/llamagirl28/719283327167873024/merlin-brings-you-an-excit...- the galahad portraits are at the very end of the post. 

As for other characters, there aren't any portraits out yet, but if you scroll back far enough on the tumblr- say to 2022- you'll be able to find the picrews she did of the cast! 

Edit: Also if you head over to the pinterest boards as mjmjh said, you get a really good feel as to the overall aesthetics of each character in game!

(+1)

Hey, is there a discord server where I can talk with ppl about this game?

No idea; if you figure that out, please let me know!!

(+2)

https://discord.gg/8dt2gnTe- link to the discord! 

this link has expired D:

Oh mein gotten that is insane,,,,truly 

Link: https://discord.gg/kZS23pdu 

(+1)

you have saved me.... I have a place to talk about my beloved gally........ty!!

I LOVE THIS!!! I've always loved the Arthurian legend, and being able to go through it interactively is a dream come true!

Btw, how long do you intend for this to be by the end? (doesn't need to be exact, just a ballpark estimate is fine, again, love your work)

(+2)

According to the tumblr (don't quote me it's been a while) book 1 is expected to be somewhere between 14-16 chapters, and there are going to be 4 installments in total for the series. 

(+4)

I’m already dating Gawain with my eye on Gally (long-term goals). I am fairly confident that as soon as things start to turn around with Galahad, Isac and Agravain are gonna walk in and sweep me off my feet, forcing me to reevaluate my plans again lol. 

(+1)

literally me kissing and holding hands with gawain, already planning how i'm gonna make galahad's heart mine 💀 i can't help but make my characters serial flirts even when they're CHILDREN, for god's sake. i feel like one of mordred's terrible caretakers, but in the love department...

(+1)

stop this image is so real 😭

like Morgana I don’t give a shit if vengeance is my birthright I want  a pony for my birthday I'm twelve.

(+3)(-5)

NO WHO AM I GOING TO CHOOSE SHOULD I WAIT FOR GALAHAD OR GO FOR ELAINE??

(+2)

cant wait for more

(+3)(-1)

I can't get enough of this. Morgana my beloved tbh 

Viewing most recent comments 1 to 40 of 324 · Next page · Last page