Comments

Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.

Viewing most recent comments 426 to 465 of 645 · Next page · Previous page · First page · Last page

what does the Yao's letter to Chang translate to?

(+6)

I am a Chinese,please forgive my poor English ability.

Yao‘s letter :

Help my friend if you want to sleep with me again.

After all,that is your only chance to revenge.

thanks

(+2)

Revenge? The story is getting interesting...

(+5)

i recently realized something, that in order to get the good ending in the game of the Echo series you often need to give your love interest what they NEED not what they WANT. spoliers for Carl,Leo,Jenna and William's route:

in Carl's route you need to turn down Carl's ideia of letting James I posses him 

in Leo's route you have to tell Leo that things between them are over

in Jenna's you have to disagreed with her cynic statements at least once

in William's route you need to take Nik's side over William's in the issue of the bridge

now this next part is speculation, i believe that the wrong choise when comforting William after he finds out his wife and son are in town is to tell him you think his duty to his family is noble  because you are basically telling him that stayng in the closet and marring and having a family with a woman you don't love for no other reason aside that it is what society expects of him makes him vituous and i think this will lead him to choose his family over Samuel down the line

after you get out of the cave , i think telling William that theres nothing wrong with him is the wrong choise, not only is the only choise where you don't take the group picture but looking at the other options they are all about telling William not to trust his senses, in Murdoch 's route Murdoch and Ralph tell us that William is vey logical and trust his senses and that this will lead him to get to the wrong conclusions which is what i belive this choise is about

Wrong book?

what?

(+3)(-1)

Leo doesn't really have a good ending but sure.

(1 edit) (+3)

i disagree, Leo's route may not have a "happy" ending but it does have a "good" ending

Well, I think it's considered to be a good ending is due to the fact he's finally over Chase and getting the help he needs or at least working towards it.

from the TVTropes page:  Chase makes peace with his ex, finds new love and escapes the town with the rest of his friends... but is still plagued by nightmares while Leo's life remains stagnant in Echo and he chooses to cut off contact with Chase entirely, although he is at least recovering from his obsession with their relationship

I'd like to thank you I checked the website you mentioned, and it answered some questions even I had and cleared things up for me.

true

(+1)

Wow, what a big spider ...I'm scared :(((

(+1)

i liked to meeting the Moore brothers 

is fun to meet the ancestors of the Echo gang

also Nik's last name finally revealed (i think,maybe it was already revealed and i didn't noticed) Krol, i guess that comfirms he is from AltPoland

(1 edit) (+1)(-2)

"App not installed."

-Android

Fix: Uninstall previous app version.

Caveat: Lose all saved data...

(1 edit)

You can always back up the save games in the android>data>echoproject.smokeroom folder before uninstalling the old build and restore it after installing the new version ;)

(3 edits) (-1)

May I ask something quite blunt... HOW THE FUCK DID THE STORAGE SPACE INCREASE SO MUCH???? I get it's a big game but I've seen bigger with 1/3 of this like what the hell, I don't know if it's bad compression or laziness but please don't let this go over 1gb

I'm sorry if this comes of as rude but you gotta see the problem in this

(+3)

There's lots of backgrounds and music and sprites, and there's more coming. The only way to reduce file size is to fragment the sprites and I do not have the time or funding to do that myself, haha. 

Somebody offered but didn't really go through with it. 

-George

Understandable, but I really do hope this gets address in the future 

Have a nice day

I found Nate's sprites in the game files (that person who tried to take Nik's hat), but they are just blank png pictures. Is it supposed to be like that?

If i am not mistaken the pictures of locations are supposed to be without cast because their spirits are just insert into those backgrounds.

I checked the development log and found no update data for android. Is this the cause of the failure to install TSR?


(+3)

Yao is da best husbando change my mind 

any attempt at downloading the android version leads to an "app not installed" error... anyone know how to fix this? i really wanna see this new update :[

Either delete the old version or empty up a huge amount of space and try again

Yeah I have the same problem too :(

I thought I was the only one who had that problem ;)

It happened something similar to me, when downloading the file Android blocks it and says "prohibited"

same I even cleared up 6gb of space and nothing

(+2)

Dimitri is packing so much charm I can't for the life of me, handle it! 👀💦💦💦 Protect this man at all costs! 

https://www.personality-database.com/subcategory/19645/the-smoke-room-gaming-mbt..

How do I update without losing my save

there's a file named saves, just copy it to the new game file

I am on mobile

Why is the Android version not working? It says that the app cannot be installed. Can someone help me?

Am I going to get existential dread or absolute cuteness this patch. YOU CAN NEVER TELL!

(+1)

updates are always worth the wait, especially when nik's turn rolls aroun

Remember the path! Good luck <3

Some of you might get it-

(+1)

Actually, I got confused because what the game seems to ask you is the sequence, not going backwards. But that still doesn't entirely fit make sense.

Maybe the devs can tell us.

(+3)

New update!!!!

Wait... Where is the download? I legit can't find it help!

(+3)(-1)

Maldita sea me quiero coger a William Adler!!!

(+1)

I've downloaded 3 VNs at the same time (TSR included), but I can only play 2 of them (TSR not included). I wonder what is the cause. Why every time I open this VN it always comes out (quit) by itself. 

Maybe someone can help me to fix it? :" )

(+1)

Let me guess you have an Android 11?

If so I have that same problem

If that's the cause, then I can't play this VN, so sad.

Yeah sadly

i think is because i dowloaded the new software because i was able to play just fine before :(

When is this game going to be updated? Aren't updates usually like monthly-? If so, at least for this game, then why has it been over a month and a half with no updates-? Not hating or anything like that, merely wondering why it's taking a while, love the game and can't, but sadly have to, wait for more content/story to play! <3  <3  <3  <3

Deleted 2 years ago

Hey, if anyone could help that would be great, but every time I try to download the smoke room all I get are all of the different files for the game, and the game itself never opens. Does anyone know a fix?

You have to extract the files from the ZIP file they come in. Winrar is usually what people use it. After downloading winrar (free), right click the game and there should be the option to "Extract" the game from the files.

I watched in Twitter that you bring another update for this game, but I wonder when you will upload it here? I really love the spoiler from Nik🥺👉👈

Please, I wants see it

(+2)

i think it was a patreon update, the free update for us will be released later

I recently downloaded this game on my android, but the app always exits by itself when I start it. Does anyone know the cause?

(1 edit) (+2)

When the new update gets released for patreon members, how long it takes to get released publicly?

generally 2 weeks

(+2)(-1)

i'd like to suggest adding a Japanese character with the name "Yagami" into The Smoke Room.

Two reasons:

1. Yagami means "night god" in Japanese, fitting for the theme.

2. Now read "Yagami" backwards...

(+1)

Socket Face が夜神 (Yagami) ですよ.

Yagami backwards is 神夜 (Shinya).

(+3)(-1)

Fuck ... NO, NO, GOD! Echo influenced me too much ... WHY AM I ALREADY PLAYING THIS FOR AN WHOLE HOUR?! I'm sure the ending won't be very positive! WHY THE FUCK, WHY ?!

Sad to say that my financial situation has taken a significant turn for the worse. Hope I can resume supporting you financially again very soon.

(1 edit) (+2)

am i the only one that has a really good feeling about William's route?

i think it might be TSR's equivalent to Jenna's route

Yeah, me too .William's route is the first route i choose because he is a sheriff so he can protect the protagonist .

I felt Will = Leo. They're both canines (go ahead and call me speciest, but they also...), have a strong sense of justice, is a leader in their own communities, and fancies the main character. And ofc, they're both big, buff, tall, strong, husky, hunky good bois with guns~

(+5)

(+1)

This is adorable, where did you find this?

(+1)

The forbidden site thats starts with an e and ends in 1.

(1 edit)

Spoilers (i think)















He's always driven by rage in his route tho when it comes to his wife and the town, hallucinations gets the better of him at the cave in the lake (the small fight with nik and william on the bridge) so its better to lay low on your expectations, but who knows :3c

I doubt the "rage" is strong enough to encompass the entire town. And where did you get "always"? If you haven't read carefully, Will communicated that he actually cared for his wife and child just as a good husband and father is as expected by society. His problem is not being true to himself, but that does not warrant mass hysteria. He already receives gratification in TSR from Sam, so we can rule out rage. Funny how you tell us to "lay low on [our] expectations," but just earlier you told us yours...wut.

(4 edits) (+1)

idk, william tends to be careless letting his rage gets on whenever his wife goes in the topic, he receives gratification from sam, yes but i dont think its sufficient enuff, william looks like he lets his guard down on the topics about his wife, the update aint finish besides its only a theory 

also that lay low on expectations is a warning lmao you can listen to it or not, besides, there's always what you call hope on this kind of things 

spoilers





also the sounds he heard from the cave is mostly woman voice, or woman's laugh  which gets me into a theory bout his problem with his wife he doesnt love them gives me the theory he had is with his wife, feels like there's a bigger picture more and more 


also its a mass hysteria(?) "each of their own" problems it doesnt just goes with william what im trying to say its not just william who's experiencing it but people who did something  and regrets it ( i think?) lol

(1 edit)

It's not about "listen[ning] to it or not," it's about committing the double standard. You tell people to "lay low on expectations," yet you, despite "spoiler warnings" (which is technically not spoiler if not officiated by the devs; thus, borderline fanfiction) constantly project onto other people your expectations regardless of how low it is. Don't get me wrong, I am open-minded, and I love discussions, but I disagree with some of your arguments.

(2 edits)

i see, well i just put spoilers  since its  safe to be sorry doesnt hurt to be safe
(^∀^●)ノシ

(+1)

Honestly, I don't feel anything about Nik's route, like I can't seem to connect on an emotional level as I did for Will, Cliff, and Murdoch. Maybe reading the dialogue with Yao felt...forced (using big words) and artificial (monotone) to compensate for a lack of fluency in English while Nik takes a back seat, a third wheel, in character and plot development; to me, it feels more like Yao's route than Nik's route what with the amount of screentime they get, more and less, respectively.

(+1)

In a sense it’s true but the next public update should be Niks and it’s very exited to see more. I don’t know what’s in the update so I do hope Nik does get more screen time

(2 edits) (+6)

Nik's is one of the shortest routes currently but will have the largest update on the patreon today. It also changed writers, abruptly, so there's a lot of setup I had to do to establish its direction. But there is a lot more Nik in Nik route coming, don't worry.

His whole route is more or less about echo's working class, so it will have a lot of characters in it before the end beyond just Nik or Yao.

-George

(+1)

the reason i have a good feeling towards William's route is because it's the only route where Sam, Nik, Cliff, William and Murdoch are all in good terms with each other and with exception of Cliff all know about Sam's secret so if any route has the most potencial for a happy ending ala Jenna's route is this one.

(1 edit) (+2)

This one thooo i did all the routes for the current version and all of them are worth it as fuq <3 they're all so good i dont know who to pick ;_; 

but i swear im going on shutdown if they did william and nik dirty just like they did to "someone" ;w;  but, even so what's a novel without bad ending? since this is a prequel to echo might as well not expect something called happy ending 

but the only promise i can give ya'll is THE WAIT IS WORTH IT

Mentally prepare to shutdown with a box of tissues by your side because Jenna's route. May I remind you that Chase, in one of his psychotic episodes, recalls the memories of a certain elderly albino feline before he [redacted] how he, I paraphrase, had said that his friends were taken away by the malevolent forces of Echo.

(2 edits)

I prepared myself for the worst Leo fuck me up on that game already ;_;  time to continue playing echo then ;w; i only did leo, and carl's route but time to continue it x'<

But there's a chance that's not them because you know TSR happened way backk thenn ;w;

What do you mean by that last part? TSR is set in 1915.

Yes, Leo's bad ending fucked me up too as did many of us. I at least half expected him to rescue Chase when he was [redacted] in the [redacted], but devs be like, the way I interpret it, too cliche or toxic relationship equals bad; thus, no redemption for Leo. Clingy doggos like him just want love, but the otter ran away...TWICE.

(1 edit)

I just finished jenna's  route and  fucking helllll


spoilerrsss 













but leo's obsession up to the point where its not  love anymore tbh, it fucked me up too but after finishing jenna, not anymore also the thing leo did with _______  which is why i think chase deserve someone better other than leo .

also i saw that psychotic episode that you mentioned with jenna it really is "him" cries more he's the one in chase's mind  right in the beginning it really is him  ;w;

(shadow chase gon give me nightmares tonight)

(+1)

Idk if its just me but the android version isnt working 😢

Same for me.

The app always says "App isn't installed" or "App cannot be installed" even though I have enough space on my phone (32GB). 🙄

(+1)

Hey guys! I'm a relatively new reader, though I've read echo already, but i was wondering if the next update will be Niks, I'm assuming so, but i just want to be shure

Heyo! I believe the next logical step would be Nik as the others have all been updated thus far. Of course, I am not certain! :)

(+1)

I found some pattern in the updates, and from it I'd expect Nik to be next (or a combo update with Nik + William)

(+1)

thank you both for telling me! I appreciate it

(+15)

(+2)

Has anyone been on Echo utah?,the place is a hell of a ghost town over 49 people live there also the founder of the place is james bromely but in this game version is james hendricks and the first business building at echo utah is makes since the saloons and brothels somehow before echoproject or..... forgot their old name ,found echo utah (not populated small town) decides to start making it a furry visual novel awesome! Tho......just a big fan of dis VN and decides to study the real echo 

(2 edits)

just played new update and wondered what pueblo exactly is considering it was on Dev's tshirt on Arches and was mentioned on said update, is it like a state or town near echo?


edit: loved the update btw, u never cease to impress! <3

(+1)

College.

(+1)

Maybe Pueblo, Colorado?

soo... does that mean echo exists in the map as well?

(+1)

if so then i would say that echo is Utha from what the art in the game looks like but it could also be that echo is Texas

(+2)

According to the following site, Echo is based on Echo, Utah and the surrounding area.  https://echoproject.fandom.com/wiki/Echo_(Town)

As for my belief that the Pueblo mentioned refers to Pueblo, Colorado -- Colorado is near Utah and Chase certainly could have gone to college in Colorado.

And remember -- TJ went to a Christian university named "CCU" -- and there is a college named Colorado Christian University. So, I believe Chase, Jenna, TJ and Carl went to college in Colorado.

(+3)

2015 echo was based a mix of echo utah and Nothing arizona. 

1915 echo is based more on those plus El Cerro Gordo California. 

It's a mix of the Southwest. 

Hi guys! I got this problem where at the start of the game it crashes.can someone help me?

delete redownload maybe

Idk tho when I play other vn like sileo it crashes for some reason

Wish there was a route for Todd, what a cute hunk~! Though..., SOMEONE has to continue the Bronson line and eventually produce the bastard child.

(+1)

I ship these bois HARD!

Me want cute hunky otter. Man If Sydney had to grow up, he'd certainly look like Todd. All laidback and amicable but we both know that won't come true since he's into wrestling and all that. Also he's already dead, unless he's somehow resurrected by unknown means or whatever.

Me want hunky muskshit and muscle yote in the same room with albino meowsir. If you played Flynn's route, Sydney would look just like how he described himself with some genetic features from his great(?) grandotter, of course.

I wonder when next update is idk

(-1)

Look at Development Log, and do some basic math.

(+3)

The Development Log doesn't show a consistent track-record of dates. The game gets updated whenever Team Echo feels ready to push updates. No need to be condescending with your "do some basic math".

It really IS basic:

Total amount of days between updates ÷ number of updates = rough average number of days between updates

(3 edits)

As I said before, Team Echo updates the game whenever they feel it ready. A "rough average" does not play out here, because since 2021, updates took 1.5 -2 months to be here, while in 2020, they took ~1 month each (with the exception of 1).

So, your "rough average" is between 1 month (at best) to 2 months (at worst), which is a long time in between anyway.

Therefore, 1 to 2 months, or 1.5 (the average of 1 + 2).

according with The Echo Project Wiki Cliff and Nikolai are from the Echo Universe  equivalent of the Netherlands and Poland respectively, but there weren't any links to official sources, Batavia being EchoNetherlands makes sense, Cliff speakes Dutch, he mentions the country being flat and the real life region of Batavia is in the Netherlands,  but the only evidence that  could find that Lakhia is EchoPoland is that Nik mentions that Lakhia is in Eastern Europe, so is Lakhia Poland or is this a case of wiki vandalism?

What prevents Nikolai from being Russian?

Ikr, especially when he mentioned vodka.

Viewing most recent comments 426 to 465 of 645 · Next page · Previous page · First page · Last page