Comments

Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.

Viewing most recent comments 37 to 76 of 336 · Next page · Previous page · First page · Last page
(1 edit) (+2)

I just finished playing Bewitching Sinners for the second time in three days and I'm honestly impressed by the amount of content and the quality of this game —Even more knowing it was created in 1 year and a half 💕


I absolutely loved the interactivity of the gameplay, and I spent so many hours exploring the map, talking with each person and going back to do as many choices I could make. 

The dialogues and interactions between all the characters were both funny and entertaining.

[Spoiler and question about the ending]

Right now I've done:

- Meyza's Happy Ending

- Io's Happy Ending

- Ivar's Happy Ending

- Seth's Happy Ending

- Seth Alternative Ending

- Palmier's Happy Ending (I think?)


But this is where I'm confused... because I did everything for "Palmier's Happy Ending": asked for the truth with Ivar, unlocked the Diary quest & Finished the Diary Quest, but the Ending was called "Your Happy Ending" so I'm not sure if I got the right one or if I messed something up and got the true "Your Happy Ending" (Ignorance is Bliss) instead of Palmier's Happy Ending... 😭

Basically, in the one I got, we go put the heart in "Non-MC-Palmier", he wakes up, we celebrate the MC departure, then Palmier (The MC) is back home with one of the guy, they meet their neighbours and then we have a glimpse of "Non-MC-Palmier" world were he talks about the witches and summon "Furry-Ivar"

Is it "Your Happy Ending" or "Palmier's Happy Ending" ? 🥲

Anyway, thank you for this game! It was amazing <3

(2 edits)

ah that’s the right one it was kinda a pun since you know non mc and mc are technically the same person so i used your for both. you have all endings! Sorry for the confusion 

No worries! I'm relieved to hear that ahah, I just wanted to make sure!

Also, I was wonderding, is it possible for the MC to go back to his world without a boyfriend? (If he rejects the crushes when they ask him or if we choose to keep going for Thane's interactions/scenes even when he is bonded with Fia/or cured)

Or will the game automatically makes us go with the crush we have the higher score with?

(1 edit)

you can go back to your world single. If you do this and have one of the bad endings and truth tag on, you all will play dnd with the boys of mc’s world haha

(+1)

I can't believe the game came out! I can't express how happy I am right now!!

(+2)

Spoilers

Arshem really got done dirty by our doppelganger. Like WTF… I was shocked. WHY are they like that!!! And the amount of fear I had anticipating his reaction to finding out our true identity ☠️ Miss Xero please stop breaking my heart!

(+2)

Ditto, he was my first route and i was like if i was him i wouldn't even forgive the doppelganger lol

(1 edit) (+2)

RIGHT?? Spoiler







 The fact that he can still even save you in that moment, like he still holds you closest to his heart… that’s a real dedicated/obsessed man right there. And then the roles reversed and I chased him around, talk to me dammit!!! Not me missing his sweet talk and softness for our character 😭😂

(+1)

Ivar doesn't have a route with a happy ending yet right? will he ever have a route? I'd like to somehow make him happy his story resonates in a way I wasn't expecting.

I mean i got a ending that said it was his happy ending, didnt seem very happy though

(2 edits) (+3)

Hmm if u mean the happy in our standards, as of right now, no. The closest is maybe in Palmier’s  (the non mc one) True Ending. And the more revenge version of happy is his own happy ending.

 if I reach a 20K gross profit, I do plan a dlc for ivar not only a route but an ending

Well Fingers crossed its reached then, He's a horribly tragic character. Characters with past of SA tend to resonate with me as someone who is a victim of that myself, (Though I say past its never really over for him is it?)

I wish there was an option to say to him he has sad eyes because personally, I think he does even if that's not mentioned. How could you not? 

Unrelated little option of mine Personally id rather have a route for Siren boy rather then Seth as honestly I think Seth is too dislikeable to have his own route but then siren boy is soul bounded so boo

(1 edit) (+1)

very understandable, tbh Irwin was supposed to be an mc of another game I scrapped so I get it and yes Seth is an ass, but like Io, Kor and Ivar, he has a story to tell (which I had to cut for time in the current game) so I want to share it if I can!

Also, thank you for saying he resonated with u, though I am sorry for the reason. I hope ur doing well.

(+2)

Definitely worth the money imo. I feel like I'm gonna have to space my runs out more, getting Palmier's ending first then Ivar's. I didn't think it'd be so drastic, but I love that it went there. All the characters were really enjoyable.

(+2)

i can't believe it's finally complete , while i was cleaning my gmail i found the notice lmao if not i would had not known !

(+1)

Look forward for the Steam release! I absolutely loved the demo so can’t wait to play! One question; how much time can I expect to spend for each route and for completionist? I saw that you put “days or more” per session but want a more accurate estimate, if possible? Thank you so much for making this game! 

(+1)

when I try to test everything (and I do mean everything from each routes and each ending) it took me over 20 hrs lol. There were a lot of replays. Ina sum though per ending is about 8 hours.

(+1)

thanks a lot for your answer! I love to play through every single routes in dating sims so this will be quite the ride

I simply could not wait any longer for the steam release so I went ahead and got it, absolutely love the story so far! There’s so much to explore and I’m obsessed. Arshem is definitely a favorite so far… but this man has issues!!

Congrats on release!! I cant really afford to buy the game rn but hopefully i can try to buy it once it comes out on steam. Really loved the game when i played the demo so Congratssss

(+1)(-1)

there was no way I was going to wait for steam to not be slow so I bought it here I did get to play some and what I played was amazing of course I have my favorite guy already Arshem 

(1 edit)

Steam really be slow though, I submitted the build for review on the 18th for review. And from my experience they do be taking 5 business days instead of 2-3, well there was a weekend so I understand

My game crashes when I try to load a save file, and it will not let me start from a save. It makes me restart the game fully. Is there something I can fix

(5 edits) (+1)(-2)

Have you tried moving all the saves from the previous v 1.1 to the new v 1.2 game folder? If the problem persists then for now please play the v 1.1 version you previously downloaded as I try to see and find a fix

I'm sorry for this inconvenience , as this is a new issue

can i only pay with paypal? pls someone say no

(+3)(-1)

for now yes, sorry as Im still testing if I use a system that allows for itch io to take stripe, will the money go to my account or not. Once I know it works then I will change it so it doesn’t only accept paypal. This process takes 10 days or so to test.

Hey! First of all, congratulations!! I've been waiting for the release of the game so eagerly!! The artwork is absolutely stunning, and the story is very compelling.

So, I might need help with locating the game key you sent. "itch io Patreon access link" to all those who have been previously subbed to the ~15€ tier, I just cant seem to be able to locate mine.

What to do? Been through Itch like a madwoman, trying to find it...
Thank you and sorry!!!

(I sent the same msg on Patreon too, didn't know which you preferred for these sort of messages.)

Sent you the link via Patreon, so sorry for the delay in response, been hectic!

(1 edit)

wow okay I cant believe it's been almost 10 months since I finished the demo. the art is gorg. I just finished my first run after 9ish hours and I'm really interested in how the story could end any differently. also so hoping for the 20k goal in your other post, seth/ivar routes would be insane.

but I'm still confused on how the curiosity/honesty/kindness stats affect anything. I ended with 20 kindness and was still called a goody two shoes so I don't think that's it. also, the gifting is kinda confusing. it always shows up as none, like the honey pops I crafted before a date

(3 edits) (+3)

Hi! Hoped you enjoyed the game! 

Still awhile for 20K but we've passed the halfway point for the 10K gross profit though! So hopefully it keeps going I can publicly release the r18 DLC here when it's done

The kindness/honesty/curiosity help a lot with your exploration and love route choices.

For example you can't hug Thane in the late night lake event unless your kindness is at 50 , Can't hug Quill either during his love route event if your kindness is below 20. The siren will snap at you for touching them if your kindness is too low.

Some of MC's dialogue will automatically be brutally honest if their honesty is above a certain point. Like inappropriately blurting out they like soap operas in the lake awakening event.  For curiosity, you need at least 50 to reach parchment 7, etc

Everyone will still call you a goody two shoes though, because let's be honest... you're a saint compared to any of them in their world.


For gifts, they should have popped up as I seem to have no issues with it, but I'll try to test that out in other computers, may I know your device? Mac? Windows?

(1 edit)

it was definitely a treat, I actually laughed aloud a lot which I don't think has ever happened to me with VN, or at least for a long time. fingers crossed for continued momentum!

& thanks for the explanation, I was so confused with the crossed out options. huge + for replayability.


I played on Win 11 on version 1.1 (I don’t know if it was fixed in 1.2). I’ll try and see what’s going on next time I’m able.

absolutely loved playing this game. i've had a couple of endings, and romanced 3/4, definitely worth the money!! if there's ever going to be a ivar's route (either here or patreon), you bet i'm going to buy it, bc ouuuff i love him. he's complicated and what not, but he's my fave. soo might just romance his son for now lol

(+1)

I love it so much. I love Arshem more than I should TvT

I am so excited to play this game. I got my key from Patreon, I had been waiting for this game to release for a long time, and it's finally here. Thank you for making this game.

Hi ! I saw you already said to another player we could pay with paypal or stripe but when I want to pay itch.io only propose paypal. I verified with another game which proposes paypal and stripe. Did I miss something somewhere ? Sorry to bother you with this. *Hides.* (Unfortunately Steam is not an option for me.)

(1 edit)

I realize now why my game only allows paypal, but I will get back to you on that as I am testing something with the payment method first

Nop. I still can't. I only get the paypal option.

Great ! I'll cross my fingers ! ~

Hello ! I was hoping to hear some good news from you ~. Did you find a solution to buy your game with a normal cb card  and no paypal account ? I know another creator had this problem once and told in a post (I think or maybe it was a reply) she just had to check a case. I hope to play your game soon and if it's not possible still thank you to have tried. Your demo was a delight to play ! ~ 

if you are still using cc to pay, have you tried via steam? I have tried to enable the cc but had reasons to just keep using paypal

Unfortunately it's more expensive on Steam for my country than on itch.io, plus I have an issue with my Steam account so I won't buy it on Steam. 

AAHHHH!!!! IT'S FINISHEDDD, thank you for all your work! i've been a long-time silent follower of this game and i'm so happy to see that's it's finished, i'll save up to buy this game so i can finally have the full experience for myself~  congratulationsss!

AHH OMG ITS FINISHED??? i remember playing the demo when it first came out and loved it !! tried exploring everything and doing all the missions etc. 

am sadly a broke student so cant afford to buy the game rn but i will in the future !!

congrats to u and lots of love <33

(-1)

OMG I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS FOR SO LONG

i do have a question when will it be available on steam?

(+1)

may 9th, assuming the build passes their review it’s still in review queue so I can’t say for sure but fingers crossed 

(1 edit) (+2)(-1)

[spoiler] Man getting that Ivar ending on first playthrough is foul. I'm so mad!Especially since game gave me the hints, I just tralalaed because man pretty and sad.

  • get genuinely scared of the man in the demo
  • IMMEDIENTLY forget about it when the game comes out
  • ''would you want to know the truth no matter how hard it is?'' girl I'm nosy obviously (🤦)
  • stare at this stupid rune for the entire game (oh is that a rose? fits the flower man nod nod)
  • ROSE Of Hecate mentioned
  • ROSE OF HECATE said to let you jump bodies
  • ROSE. OF. HECATE. (aAAAAAAAAAAAAA)
  • backstory revealed (and I'm just gonna say it was so cruel, but made so much sense for his character and made sympathising with him so easy)
  • he LOVES his sons!! the circumstances are just real dire!!!
  • we hug! (did he enchant my ass there? is it physical touch for him? is that why I didn't get the option to smooch? am I that easy????)
  • he says he will probably help us (owo)
  • Io says he likes us (owo) (definetely not biased or trying something)
  • Io is pretty unproblematic and goes down pretty easily 👍(headmaster who)
  • he saves our ass
  • why is a rune there? don't worry about it babygirl okay yippie!
  • our girlboss girlfailure other self wakes up 😃
  • we say goodbye to everyone and it's all very wholesome! <3
  • ''would you still like to know the truth?'' kinda sus but okay ''why are your eyes-?'' ANYWAY NOT MY PROBLEM ANYMORE
  • 3 months long Bahamas holiday with Quill (YIPPIE) 💖💖
  • wtf are we dreaming about
  • he wants to say goodbye maybe??? some plot details???
  • GIRL WHAT
  • KOR COME PICK ME UP I'M SCARED
  • Ivar: I know you like them so I cut their pain receptors :3
  • Me: pikachu face
  • I have so many questions
  • Did his curse also transfer?? Did it not, but he just didn't feel safe as a last witch?? Is he waiting for it to weaken??  Was somebody mean to him?? Where tf is Lyall??? Was it his plan all along?
  • at least we got Quill out...?
  • FIAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!!!
  • ''thanks to your friendship-'' I SHOULD HAVE LEFT YOU AT THAT CORNER I FOUND YOU
  • (Quill also tried to choke me and I still went with his so maybe I'm the problem?)
  • How are you gonna get laid now fool??? You ain't got no daughter to led down to altar??? What about your dreams?? OR did he only get humans??
  • How big a concussion do we need to forget all that?
  • AAAAAAAAAA
  • Quill is gonna get one funny story when we wake up
  • Is Ivar gonna bring us back again? So he doesn't feel lonely? Will he not let us leave? Is it a one time thing?
  • I do feel like we had something there but my god some rules don't fix morality
  • Palmier needs lobotomy and so do I

I'm both so mad and impressed, because this is such a good bad ending:

1. Is genuinely heartwrenching

2. Makes sense

3. Is more of a sum of choices that lead you there than one silly choice you make at the end of the game

4. The game gives you hints and from what I've seen in the guide there a few ways to prevent this


Now APART from all of that:

  • I really like fishing (it's so easy and simple and let's you get stupidly rich so fast)
  • the characters are great (really liked Quill's plot twist)
  • the pacing is just right
  • the weird morality really helped to establish that this is a different world from our own and the entire worldbuilding was both really funny and really enjoyable
  • our Palmier just trying to get some more time with their sister is so sweet and sad
  • this world Palmier is so messy and I stan
  • the strap joke took me out
  • I'm sorry Poppy 🙃

I had to take a nap before writing this cheers

(1 edit) (+2)

Reading all that make me soooo happy you cannot believe! But perhaps you can add the comment [spoiler] hehe just so the others will also have a blank slate > <

Also yesh, the way to get the only way to get the True Ending is to finish Palmier's Diary Quest hehe , although having either Seth's or Ivar ending will at least let you see the boys 3 months after endings since I want your pain for being brave enough to accept the truth to mean something!

Also if you do get the True Ending, you will get another side to Ivar hehe!

(2 edits) (+4)

I'm so glad to see its official release! I had a blast playing the demo, the writing is fun and the art is stunning

Can't wait for the game's Steam release since I don't have a Paypal lol

(1 edit)

The game is still in steam review queue at the moment, so I'm afraid I can't answer that for sure, but I'm hoping it will be okay and ready to publish on May 9th

TY for replying! I hope things go well with the review queue

(+1)

im sorta confused i followed the guide (i think hehe)  and Thane still ends up with Fia T-T 

also how do you unlock the option to hug Thane in the fish... scene ??

(10 edits) (+2)

in order for Thane not to end up with Fia you need to do finish the Find the Culprit quest right after defeating Meyza at the latest> Then when Thane attacks Fia instead of Winston , you need to agree to come with Thane to talk to her and apologize > this will make Thane not immediately bond with Fia the day after and open a new sleepover event with the boys > Then do not cure thane by brewing the blood potion cure > after Io’s arc is done and they insert her heart to Palmier, this should later prompt Thane to ask you to bond > Say yes


Hope this helps? Thane’s route is a bit  complex because it changes a lot of other events in game so yeah, there is a chain reaction but as far as I know from my patrons they all were able to do it eventually so hopefully shud not be an issue


to open the option to hug Thane you need a kindness of minimum 50 points

(+1)

thank you sm !! <3

Wait do I need to get a paypal account to buy this game? Is that the only way?

(1 edit) (+2)

from what I read in itch io detail it’s either paypal or stripe https://itch.io/docs/creators/payments

If both are not available to you, then please wait for the steam release 

Sorry for your inconvenience 

(1 edit) (+2)

OH SORRY I JUST FIGURED IT DW! THANKS FOR TRYNA HELP THO :3c

Can’t wait to play the game once my exams are over :’3c

(+3)

im from patreon and omg this game is so amazing. i love that we can play as a girl and the MC has a great personality. and the art is so good and the guy sooo hottt

Love the game! but question. I hope this doesn't sound stupid nut where you could get Quality Ink...? 

you make it after getting the recipe from ink quest 2, please refer to the guide for a more detailed explanation, it’s at the quests tab!

(+1)

<3 Yaaaaaaaaas

(+1)

Beautiful game with stunning visuals! I’ve only played a handful so far from one of the later demos on patreon, so I’m excited the play the full game! Congratulations for all your work. I hope your game does amazing, and I’ll be telling my friends to check it out as well!

(+2)

I'm coming from your patreon, just wanna say that this game is amazing and so proud of all the work you've done on this! I'm really in love with each and every character.

thank u! If u like the game please consider leaving a review or just fill the star rating! Only if u want to tho!

(1 edit)

is there anyway to sell your items? I don't know how to/not even sure if this is a feature lol 

(+1)

you can only sell your fish, to the guy in front of the shops in the shops area!

thank you so much! :D

(1 edit) (+2)

I also added it to my wishlist on Steam, Will I receive a Steam key if I pay here? I want to buy it and play it quickly, but when will it be available for purchase on Steam?

(+2)

im planning on May 9th but right now the game is still in steam’s review queue so I can’t say for sure. Fingers crossed steam finds nothing wrong with it and I can launch on steam as planned. As of right now bow due to the fact the build is still in review queue, I can’t generate keys for it. So if you buy it now, no. 

Can't pay for it yet but as soon as I can I'll buy it

1.5 years is extremely impressive, approximately how many hours would one run/route take?

(+4)

Testers average it takes 8-10 hours , but that depends on the amount of quest you do. If you try romancing all guys at once and save - load it can take to 16 hours. 

(-5)

18 dollars is alot can someone tell me if this is wroth buying

(+7)

have u played the demo ? cos even from the demo u can tell its pretty great quality - and also so far im rlly enjoying it !!!!!!!!!!!!!

OKII TY

anyone know the password for the hint "we bonded over"?? i think i missed something lol

(+1)

It's bloodmoon no caps. The hint is during convo with Quill, Thane, and also after Io's arc

THANK YOU!!

(+1)

Hi, I wanted to know if the only way to pay for the game is through paypal?:(

(+1)(-1)

def recommend you to make an paypal account, it's the safest option anyway :)

anyone who knows how to access the guide after the download? i usually use steam but couldnt wait for it to be added there, and im a guide user so reeaaally could use the help haha

you need to dowload the guide extra. 

After that open it with winrar. :)

(1 edit)

hello, yes i did download it, however, i have no idea how to access it AFTER the download. for some reasons i cant find it to actually open it with anything


edit: i just uninstalled the whole thing just to try to download the guide again, but no im just downloading the whole game? not able to find the guide in the files either so i have no idea what im doing wrong

do you have the winrar programm? You need this to unzip the files, you can find videos on ytb for that :)

(+1)

Hi there

If you still have issues with downloading the guide, you can also check the guide here : Bewitching Sinners Guide V 1.1

- Miss Xero

(+1)

OMG FINALLY

Viewing most recent comments 37 to 76 of 336 · Next page · Previous page · First page · Last page