itch.io is community of indie game creators and players
See more

Blog Post 3: Analysis of Core Systems & Structures in Silent Hill 2

Posted July 28, 2024 by 5amclouds

Introduction

Silent Hill 2 (SH 2) is a critically acclaimed survival horror game known for its detailed storyline, atmospheric tension, and psychological depth. This post explores the core systems and structures that make SH 2 a standout in the survival horror genre.

Game Mode Focus

Primary Game Mode Focus: Single Player Campaign

  • Campaign Structure: Players control the protagonist, James Sunderland, as he explores Silent Hill in search of his deceased wife, Mary. The game is deeply narrative-driven with multiple endings based on player choices.
  • Atmospheric Design: Immersive environments, pervasive fog, and a haunting soundtrack contribute to the game's unsettling atmosphere.
  • Character Development: Encounters with various characters, each with their own backstories and psychological complexities, add layers to the narrative and enhance the player's experience.

Core Systems Overview

Exploration System

  • Mechanics:
    • Free Movement: Players can explore the town of Silent Hill, including streets, buildings, and hidden areas.
    • Map Usage: The map helps players navigate and locate key areas, items, and objectives.
    • Item Collection: Players gather essential items for survival and progression, such as health items, keys, and weapons.
  • Integration with Other Systems:
    • Combat: Exploration leads to discovering weapons and health items crucial for surviving encounters.
    • Puzzlesolving: Exploration is key to finding clues and items necessary to solve the game's puzzles.
  • Example Content: Collecting a Flashlight
    • What It Is: An important item found early in the game that allows players to see in the dark.
    • Where It's Found: Typically located in dark, eerie environments like abandoned buildings.
    • Importance:
      • Navigation Aid: Enables players to see in dark areas.
      • Critical for Progression: Essential for navigating certain areas and identifying enemies.
      • Interactive Element: Attracts enemies, adding a strategic layer to gameplay.

Combat System

  • Mechanics:
    • Melee Attacks: Players use weapons like pipes and wooden planks.
    • Ranged Attacks: Guns, such as shotguns, provide long-range combat options.
    • Health Management: Players use items like health drinks and medkits to survive encounters.
  • Integration with Other Systems:
    • Exploration: Combat readiness is necessary to find weapons and health items.
    • Puzzlesolving: Some puzzles require defeating enemies to access areas or items.
  • Example Content: Encounter with Pyramid Head
    • What It Is: A recurring antagonist and iconic enemy in the game.
    • Where It's Found: Various locations, usually in confined spaces.
    • Importance:
      • High Difficulty: Requires strategic use of combat mechanics.
      • Narrative Impact: Encounters significantly impact the story, symbolizing James' guilt.
      • Fear Factor: Heightens the horror experience with terrifying moments.

Puzzlesolving System

  • Mechanics:
    • Logical Puzzles: Require players to use clues and reasoning.
    • Environmental Puzzles: Involve interacting with the environment, like moving objects or finding hidden items.
  • Integration with Other Systems:
    • Exploration: Puzzles are often integrated into the environment, requiring thorough exploration.
    • Storytelling: Solving puzzles reveals important story details.
    • Combat: Some puzzles require defeating enemies to access areas or items.
  • Example Content: Music Box Puzzle
    • What It Is: A multistep puzzle involving finding and placing music boxes in the correct order.
    • Where It's Found: Located in the Lakeview Hotel.
    • Importance:
      • Complexity: Requires collecting multiple items and understanding clues.
      • Narrative Relevance: Reveals key story elements.
      • Engagement: Provides a break from combat and exploration, adding variety.

Storytelling System

  • Mechanics:
    • Cutscenes: Advance the plot and provide character development.
    • Environmental Storytelling: Clues and details in the environment hint at the backstory.
    • Character Interactions: Conversations reveal motives and backstories.
  • Integration with Other Systems:
    • Exploration: Discovering story elements through exploration.
    • Puzzles: Story puzzles reveal plot details upon completion.
  • Example Content: James’s Backstory
    • What It Is: The protagonist's journey driven by guilt over Mary’s death.
    • Where It's Revealed: Through cutscenes, diary entries, and interactions.
    • Importance:
      • Emotional Impact: Adds depth to the narrative.
      • Narrative Depth: Explores themes of guilt, redemption, and psychological horror.
      • Player Engagement: Encourages players to piece together the story.

Game Terminology

  • Fog World: The normal version of Silent Hill, covered in thick fog, creating isolation.
  • Otherworld: A darker, grotesque version reflecting the protagonist's inner fears and guilt.

Lens Analysis

  • Lens of Obstacle: Obstacles gradually increase in difficulty, enhancing engagement and immersion.
  • Lens of the Hero’s Journey: James’s quest for redemption and understanding qualifies as a heroic journey.
  • Lens of Story: The game's story is crucial for atmosphere, character development, and emotional engagement.
  • Lens of Help: Players help James navigate through Silent Hill.

Genre and Market Groupings

  1. Survival Horror Enthusiasts
    • Appeal: Atmospheric tension, psychological horror, resource management.
    • Comparison: Resident Evil 2 - Both focus on survival elements and disturbing environments, but SH 2 emphasizes psychological horror.
  2. Psychological Thriller Fans
    • Appeal: Deep storylines, psychological themes.
    • Comparison: Alan Wake - Both offer strong story-driven gameplay, though SH 2 is more emotionally intense.
  3. Adventure and Puzzle Game Fans
    • Appeal: Puzzles, detailed exploration.
    • Comparison: Myst - Both offer complex puzzles and immersive worlds, but SH 2 adds horror and urgency.

Loops & Arcs in Silent Hill 2

  • Core Systems: Exploration, Combat, Puzzlesolving, Storytelling.
  • Smallest Loop: A single room encounter: solve a puzzle or defeat enemies, find key items, and proceed.
  • Biggest Loop: Complete journey: solve overarching puzzles, confront key story events and bosses, manage resources, and reach the story’s conclusion.
  • Comparison of Loops: Room encounters are focused and immediate. The complete journey combines many room encounters with long-term resource management and story progression.
  • Ludonarrative Arc:
    • Internal Story: James’s psychological journey.
    • Game's Story: Unfolding mystery of Silent Hill, themes of guilt, grief, redemption.
  • Smaller Arcs: Solving key puzzles, surviving specific encounters, unlocking new areas.
  • Arc-Loop Sandwich: Collecting items/solving puzzles, defeating enemies (the loop) to gather clues and resources, aiding James's psychological journey and the unfolding mystery (the arc).

Conclusion

Silent Hill 2's intricate systems and structures create a deeply engaging survival horror experience. By integrating exploration, combat, puzzlesolving, and storytelling, SH 2 delivers a compelling narrative and immersive gameplay that continues to resonate with players.



by Hasina Esteqlal

CMPM 176

Game Blog Assignment

July 27, 2024

Leave a comment