Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Itch curent system allow potential illegal activity

A topic by Deleted Account created Apr 23, 2023 Views: 592 Replies: 17
Viewing posts 1 to 5
Deleted post
Deleted post
Moderator(+3)

This is one of the reasons projects take that long to index in the search engine.

Itch.io is focusing on allowing indie devs to publish their content as easy as possible. This has its drawbacks, but it’s one of the reasons new accounts with new projects go through a review to check on this activity.

What you are describing is not unique to Itch.io, users can for example post pictures on social media that break the rules there. The picture will appear instantly, but soon after it will be taken down.

The alternative is to have stricter controls on who can make accounts and publish content, maybe even ask users to pay to publish, which honestly I think will make Itch.io lose part of its charm as an indie friendly platform. Of course every person has their own opinion :)

Deleted post

that was a long note actually

Moderator (1 edit) (+2)

People yell at us all the time because their games don't show up in searches instantly after going public. I keep having to explain them again and again that there's a review time. Or why their game has been quarantined.

Deleted post
(+3)


Your statement is trivial. It is true for all places in the internet where you can upload stuff. Welcome to the internet.

Itch does good in not telling what exactly is in place, so bad actors do not come up with methods of circumventing it.

The bad actor I saw that weekend is disapper now, but yeah, "itch  have no tool to prevent or find bad actors"..... ;-)

Deleted post
Moderator

Any game page can be quarantined. There are automatic protections, including server-side malware scans, and other methods to catch people who try to use itch.io as an attack vector. And a game page can be reported even if it's restricted, if the recipient of a link deems it suspicious. This is probably more than many other websites do to catch malicious uploads.

Deleted post
Moderator

They can much more easily use any of the countless file sharing services out there, that are completely anonymous.

rofl. safely. on a system where anyone can use report button and a bored admin could take alook or an automatic system unknown to you coulc catch you. that is not safe place to share. there are safe ways that i do not want to discuss here. We do not want to give manual to wannabe bad actors, do we.

No you were not. Or actually, what you talked about is included in what I wrote. Itch is searchable by internet should you not know.  There is no such thing as "restricted" page.  If you can share a direct link without key or password necessary, google will find it. Or is there an additional button to not make game page visible for 3d party search engine?

And even if it wereso.     how isthat any diffrent from a bad agent sharing a link to googledrive? The ydo not even scan big archieves.

You could construct  scearious where you need akey to download it, so like make the pay very big so no one who accindentaly finds page buys it,  and share link and key with your victims. But again, how is taht diffrent from sharing googledrive password protected archive.

I say again, your observation is trivial.

And on a side note from expericence with scam mails over the years i got, often the payload link is on small forum software or uploadabe usercontent there. But I have never seen payload on even remotely similar pages like itch. Why? Because itch does do remove bad agents i suspect.

for people who just uploaded  their first project is hard for them to understand some of this things ,i feel the best way to solve some of this issues is for people who has been using this platform for a long time now, try to follow back people who are following you this we help.

(+1)

When I discovered that my game didn't appear in Itch's search, I thought the reason was that it contained adult content. I would like to ask, what do you mean by bad content here? Adult games?

But the thing is, there are plenty of adult games here, and they are in the search.

Deleted post
Moderator

You just published your game yesterday. Please wait. And next time make your own topic instead of hijacking an unrelated discussion.