Hi there!
It seems to me everything is right. Let us check something:
- Are you using the Eli Book above it?
- Your event has a lot of pages, maybe there is something wrong there. So just to make sure, can you try to make the setup work on an event with only one page?
- Make sure the "Punch" label (both on the plugin parameter and on the event command) has no blank spaces. Like "Punch ".
- If everything fails, try it on a clean project, only with Eli Book and Eli Extra Trigger.
- If step 4 works, then it is a compatibility issue. Maybe some other plugin is also using the A key, or who knows. You will have to disable one plugin and test the game. If it works, then the last plugin disabled is the problem. Tell me what it is and I will take a look to make a compatibility patch.
- If step 4 does not work, take that clean project and upload it somewhere(Like, google drive, one drive, dropbox, etc...) and send it so I can take a look.
I tried to replicate your process, and it worked: