The idea of the game being the main character walking around the island before finding the horrifying secrets in the cave at the end of the game was quite well done in terms of atmosphere and mood of the environment through darkness, rain and thunder but I felt that more could have been done to make the game more horrifying. It took me about 3 minutes to finish the game and I felt that there was a lack of storytelling and logic as to why the main character follow the torches before entering a cave on a rainy night in a random island. Moreover, more horrifying elements could have been added like jumpscares or visual images to make the entire experience more horrifying and better for the player altogether.
Thank you for reading my comment and I wish you good luck in your future endeavours.