You misunderstand: to get the good routes, choose the 1st option every time EXCEPT for the second quiz. You need to get those right for Maddie's route.
Yes I did get all the questions right on both quizzes for Maddie's route, but I still wanted Lucy's route. And I think for that I need to get the second quiz wrong?
No, I had both routes and got both quizzes right. If I remember correctly, you have to take revenge on Tanya and have Lucy meet you, then kiss her in front of Tanya in order to unlock Lucy route.
