You don't lose hearts, and both can see reasons why you'd pick to go help the other. It actually might be better to go with Logan there in general, since he's a lot harder to make happy than Bernard, haha.
Right now there aren't any effects to having fun with them in your dungeon. There is a change in sentence, though, so the game does record your actions for the future.
Thanks a bunch ! Thats good to know.
I did just that, i went back and i saved logan instead. Something changed though. When the time comes where bernard invites you over at night and talk, i didn’t get the option for him to transform during the adult fun times. When i chose to save bernard, the option for him to change to a werewolf was there. Is it supposed to be like that? Or did i do something wrong?