Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
Tags
A jam submission

Melodic PlatformingView game page

Beat a platformer while creating melodies!
Submitted by dardasaba (@dardasaba6) — 5 hours, 18 minutes before the deadline
Add to collection

Play game

Melodic Platforming's itch.io page

Results

CriteriaRankScore*Raw Score
Creativity#2524.1584.158
Overall#9653.6403.640
Presentation#12913.6583.658
Enjoyment#18723.1053.105

Ranked from 38 ratings. Score is adjusted from raw score by the median number of ratings per game in the jam.

How does your game fit the theme?
The roles of a MIDI keyboard and a gaming controller are reversed, so the game is controlled by the piano roll.

Did your team create the vast majority of the art during the 48 hours?

Yes

We created the vast majority of the art during the game jam

Did your team create the vast majority of the music during the 48 hours?

Yes

We created the vast majority of the music during the game jam

Leave a comment

Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.

Comments

Viewing comments 24 to 5 of 24 · Next page · Last page
Submitted(+1)

Interesting concept, I feel like there's potential but 48h is definitely a bit short to fully develop it. As others have said, maybe something akin to the musical levels in Rayman Legends would work better?. The balance between leading the players and giving them creative liberty seems hard to find!

Developer

Yeah you said it well xD I'll have a look at Rayman Legends, never heard of it before!

Submitted(+1)

That's an interesting twist on the platformer genre, but I think the execution could use some tweaking (which is hard to get enough of in a game jam).

For example, you could try to make the levels in a way that helps to play a decent melody. Or maybe pivot the game so that it's no longer a platformer, as suggested in another comment.

As for the implementation itself, the controls felt a little floaty.

Nice visuals though. Good job!

Developer

Yep I agree that the execution is pretty meh in this one, thanks for the suggestions! Designing levels that help create good melodies is definitely smart though might be a huge pain to try to design xD

Submitted (1 edit) (+1)

Like making music while playing, but it makes holding a key a bit annoying. Also jumps are a little unforgiving for my taste. Could be really cool with more time put into level design to "force" players into making a good music

Developer

Hm, you're the first person to mention the jumps, I'll try to tinker with the variables a bit! And yeah the level design could use a lot of work

Submitted(+1)

In theory a very cool idea, saving the file you made is such a genius addition! But it doesn't particularly feel like the average person will make good music from this, which is a shame because if the level was designed differently and the other keys had functionality instead of existing as different notes there's really a lot of potential here to make a great game!

Developer(+1)

Yep this is exactly the issue I have with this game too, it's a cool idea on paper but doesn't really work the way I executed it...

Originally the E button was supposed to be a dash but I ended up cutting that out, maybe it could've helped 🤔

Thanks for the feedback!

(+1)

I think you're extremely close to an awesome idea.

Instead of it being a free moving platformer, make it a forced side scroller.

Add a drum track in the background.

Then design the levels such that if played efficiently, it will play a melody.

And score is evaluated based on how close the player was to hitting say, the nearest 16th note for any given jump or other action.

So its ALMOST like a rhythm game, but the melody is not predetermined, the player is just incentivized to play in a rhythm.

(maybe that will work)

Developer

Hm, I feel like doing that would pretty drastically change the original idea, however that's not necessarily a bad thing since as you say, this idea doesn't really work that well xD

Definitely interesting suggestions!

Submitted(+1)

Nice idea, although I think it's really really really difficult for someone to create a "melody" while trying to reach the summit, and not a series of mismatching notes xD

Developer(+1)

yep that's the main reason I'm not really happy with my game (and nearly dropped out of the jam), the idea sounded cool on paper but didn't really work out in reality...

Submitted(+1)

good game!!!

Submitted(+1)

Really great idea! My music was awful, but i had fun. maybe the character could be a little more faster and the level less vertical.

Developer

thanks for the feedback!

Submitted(+1)

Awesome concept! There's a lot more than can be done with this (maybe giving certain notes or patterns (gliss, chords, etc.) special abilities, or having a bass in the background that matches your pace), but for 48 hours u made something pretty neat

Developer

very true! At first the drums were the double jump but it didn't feel very good, maybe it would've worked with other abilities though... Thanks for playing!

Submitted(+1)

Nice idea! Using a piano instead of a controller is not changing much gameplay, but it did use the theme in a graphical way.


Nice work :)

Submitted(+1)

Super cool, I like how going left and right have nice complementary chords, especially if you add the extra notes. Intrinsically felt really enjoyable to me and it's funny to try and find a way to play that makes a nice song. Super fun! 

Developer

Thanks!

Submitted(+1)

really creative! although the platforming itself is short, attempting to make a better melody added a nice sense of replayability. great job!

Developer

yep that was the intention, making it short so that replayability won't be too tedious

Thanks for playing!

Submitted(+2)

very music. love the idea

Developer

thanks AIA! :)

Gonna watch your stream vod now, unfortunately I went to sleep right when it started

Submitted(+1)

This is such a creative game! Being able to hear what you played at the end was a nice touch that motivated me to play it again. I'm not very good at making music, but I managed to make something decent!

Developer

glad to hear you enjoyed!

Submitted(+1)

Really cool idea, and it's so fun to play! I kinda got addicted to trying to make a sick beat while still making it decently far up, lol.

Developer

haha, that was the intention though I didn't think it would actually work!

Submitted (1 edit) (+1)

This game idea has potential. Making music while platforming can be so cool. Unfortunately, it was too short, and the spacebar sound may have not been the best. However, this is a game jam, so this could be expanded into something way cooler.

Developer

it's intentionally short to allow you to replay and try to create better music without it becoming too tedious, but maybe people prefer longer levels 🤔

Also I agree the drum sound is really meh, I made it myself unlike the piano notes and it can be felt xD

Submitted(+1)

Very creative! I really love the idea!

Submitted(+1)

I love the idea! I kinda wish there was some sort of a background melody/metronome/drums to fet our music into.  But this has so much potential and would be lovely to see more developed! The saving feature is also really cool! I enjoyed it very much and replayed it a few times to mess around. :)

Developer

That's a cool idea, thanks for the suggestion!

Submitted(+1)

maybe instead of using the  C,D,E,F,G,A , you could take a 6 note chord. Then change the chord used across levels, so some levels would feel sad and other happy, for example. That could make it more interesting! Or maybe using a tremolo effect for when the character walks, so it would emulate te sound of steps. Something like that could work. :D

Developer(+1)

whoa these are all really cool ideas! Idk if I'll continue to expand this game since it's not one of my better ones, but now you're getting me kinda hyped about doing it xD

Submitted(+1)

Very creative, love the concept and the graphics

I wish the level design had a bit more of work however, very cool idea though!

Submitted(+1)

Amazing presentation and concept, incredibly creative!

Viewing comments 24 to 5 of 24 · Next page · Last page