The idea of this game is wonderful; I think smithing is somewhat of a lost art these days so a game centered on it is great. The game narrative changing depending on your performance is great too. The lore and world-building in this game is simply immense for a game which has functionally three boards/menus. I did have some notable bugs, however, when trying to play. Menus tended to clang into each other (which really became an issue if you worked out of order) and the lack of a tutorial made it a bit harder than it needed to be. But overall, this is a pleasant experience and I loved it very much.

albeit quite confusing at first, it was a fun playthrough, very cute art too! 10/10

Perhaps a bit more hints in what the metals do and or do not do. It was harder around the 6th day to figure out the best metal to use for what as it became more specific in what the client needed the weapon for or to do  but info wasn't added or updated when reaching that point. More metal options would be a way to do this I think but that's your call. lol

Very cute game. I agree with Valonad that the menus could have a better layout and it would be useful to receive more feedback after selling a weapon. The news were helpful but something more immediate could have been nice too.

I got a bit lucky with my purchases and I was able to make the weapons that the characters required despite money being very tight. I was surprised that the events depended on the kinds of weapons that you sold, that was pretty neat. I was able to get the good ending first try!

Very creative concept with cute visuals and fun writing. But I think the gameplay itself gets too repetitive and slow after a while, especially with how all the menus overlap with each other so you have to constantly open and close them. 

I feel like the game also gives you really little feedback on the weapons you create, other than how much money you get and the newspaper, unless this is supposed to be played through multiple playthroughs? Which if it is, i'd like for the smithing to be less tedious, atleast by making it so all the menus are in distinct locations so you could have all of them open all the time rather than dragging everything to the quickslot.